Hollie Davidson hailed as best referee after Argentina clash
Hollie Davidson hailed as best referee after Argentina clash

Hollie Davidson has been hailed as the "best referee in world rugby" after her performance in France's clash with Argentina, which included a contentious decision that left Pumas captain Julian Montoya furious.

The Scottish official earned widespread praise for her handling of the contest in Paris, with former England captain Will Carling among those to single her out for special recognition.

Contentious Breakdown Decision

One incident in particular caught the attention of viewers, with Davidson standing firm after Montoya angrily protested a decision at the breakdown. With France leading 26-10, a penalty was awarded against the Argentina skipper following a chaotic passage of play at a ruck.

France winger Louis Bielle-Biarrey had initially flown into the breakdown, before Montoya then attempted to steal possession, only for Davidson to penalise him for going off his feet. The Argentina captain was incensed by the decision, repeatedly shouting "It's the same!" as he pointed out what he believed was a similar infringement by Bielle-Biarrey moments earlier.

Davidson was unmoved, telling Montoya: "Off feet, you're driving over the breakdown." The exchange came during a difficult spell for Argentina, with Montoya subsequently sent to the sin bin.

Praise from Pundits and Fans

Former France hooker Benjamin Kayser, working as co-commentator, was full of praise for Davidson's handling of the situation. "Hollie Davidson, having absolutely none of it!" he exclaimed. "Julian Montoya was fuming at this decision. But I think she is absolutely spot on. The clearout from Louis Bielle-Biarrey, then [Montoya] goes around and he dives on it."

Davidson's performance throughout the contest attracted considerable attention on social media, with many supporters praising her authority, communication and consistency. Former England captain Carling was particularly impressed, suggesting she had outperformed every other official involved in the weekend's international fixtures.

Writing on X, he said: "One other observation about all the great games yesterday - how good was Hollie Davidson - I thought she was easily the best referee - eagle eyed, calm, authoritative when needed, sympathetic when needed - and used the TMO quickly and precisely - loved it."

Growing Reputation

His assessment prompted a wave of agreement from rugby supporters, who were similarly impressed by the Scottish referee's display. One fan responded: "She was absolutely tip top." Another wrote: "Absolutely. She is getting the big games based on merit alone. That's all the game wants - the best refs. She is one them." A third simply declared: "She's fantastic!"

Others suggested Davidson's rise through the refereeing ranks was an encouraging sign for rugby more generally. "Apart from her own achievements, it reflects really well on the progress the game has made," one supporter wrote. Another added: "She is a brilliant ref." One fan praised her no-nonsense approach, writing: "Well said. She's a top ref, takes no nonsense."

Davidson, 33, has established herself as one of the most highly regarded officials in international rugby, earning increasingly prominent appointments in the men's game. Her latest performance only strengthened that reputation, with another supporter writing: "100% agree - at only 33yo Hollie Davidson is a great example for those who wish to officiate at all levels in the game that we have grown to know and love."