Brian Moore backs WRU cuts as Gerald Davies questions leadership
Brian Moore backs WRU cuts; Davies questions leadership

England rugby great Brian Moore has insisted Welsh rugby cannot afford to sustain four professional teams and has challenged critics of the Welsh Rugby Union to come up with a fully-costed alternative before attacking its plans. The WRU has been criticised by former players and supporters for its decision to cut the number of professional clubs from four to three, but Moore maintains the union is right to do so if it wants competitive teams.

Moore defends WRU leadership

Writing in The Telegraph, Moore said: "Let me set out a few cold facts. If there were enough multimillionaires to support the present four regions, they would have emerged by now and they have not. Wales cannot afford four regions and emotionally wishing it otherwise does not change the maths."

He added: "If Scotland, which is a richer country on nearly every economic and resources metric, runs only two fully professional regions, why will Wales be able to do otherwise? Consider this – if the regions are not cut, Welsh domestic club rugby will never be in a position to offer salaries that are anywhere near those offered in the English Prem, where several of Wales’s best players currently ply their trade."

Moore also condemned some of the harsh criticism the WRU leadership has received and challenged opponents to come up with an affordable alternative plan. He noted that Abi Tierney, Dave Reddin and Malcolm Wall, three born-in-England outsiders singled out for criticism, were not in charge during the slow decline that led Wales to their current predicament.

"They were brought in to help, and their efforts are sincere and come with a perspective that cannot be reached by people who are intimately involved and who have regional and/or club loyalties that are difficult, if not impossible to set aside," he wrote.

Davies questions union's vision

Meanwhile, Sir Gerald Davies has questioned whether the WRU will show the leadership needed to improve the game in Wales. Steve Tandy's side ended 73 years of heartache against New Zealand at the Principality Stadium, a feat not even the great Welsh sides of the 1970s, which Davies was part of, managed.

Despite the win, Davies told BBC Radio Cymru: "New Zealand are the barometer around the world, but there's a big question about the future and where Wales goes from here. Are the administrators within the union able to show leadership and the vision to improve the state of the game in Wales?"

He added: "It is great to celebrate and correct to feel proud of what we saw at the weekend, but the big question is what about tomorrow and what is the plan? So far, I'm afraid I don't think we've seen the leadership required [from the WRU]."

Davies praised the players for raising the spirit of the nation, saying: "Wales have broken the hoodoo at last after 73 years and what we saw on Saturday certainly shows the way forward for Wales. It showed that we can play quickly, that we can stand up physically to the All Blacks and that we had the confidence to deliver."

Springboks make changes for Ireland clash

Rassie Erasmus has responded to last Friday's defeat to France by making five changes to his Springboks side for the match against Ireland at the Aviva Stadium. World class lock Eben Etzebeth returns to the starting XV, while backrower Cameron Hanekom, once Welsh-qualified, earns a start. Ox Nche, Malcolm Marx, and Wilco Louw return to the front row.

Erasmus said: "This is a massive match for us and we know the magnitude of facing Ireland in Dublin, so we felt it was important to strike a balance between consistency in selection, while managing some players and giving others who have been training hard and putting up their hands a chance in what will be a challenging encounter."

South Africa: Willemse; Arendse, Kriel, De Allende, Hooker; Feinberg-Mngomezulu, Van den Berg; Nche, Marx, Louw, Etzebeth, Nortje, Kolisi (capt), PS Du Toit, Hanekom. Replacements: Wessels, Steenekamp, T du Toit, De Jager, De Villiers, Van Staden, Williams, Moodie.