Two clubs refuse to cover legal costs if Man City sponsors sue after 18-2 vote
Two clubs refuse legal costs cover after 18-2 vote

Manchester City and Nottingham Forest were the only two clubs to vote against changes to Premier League rules that extend legal protection for board members, in an 18-2 vote at a meeting in London on Thursday.

The vote passed, meaning Premier League board members now have extra legal protection amid the threat of actions arising from the Manchester City case. Eighteen of the 20 clubs supported the changes to the league's articles, which extend protections for individual board members.

Why the rule change was needed

The issue was put to a vote to align the league's individual legal cover with that of similar companies, including many of its clubs. These articles had not been reviewed since the league's inception in 1992.

The change comes after City sponsors Etihad and Etisalat said they were considering legal action over the "damaging" implications of the independent commission's guilty verdict against the club. The companies were not named in the verdict, which found City had benefited from "sham" arrangements to inflate revenue and disguise costs to avoid breaching Premier League and UEFA rules. City have appealed against the verdict and continue to deny any wrongdoing.

City and Forest's opposition

Unsurprisingly, City opposed the measure. Despite voting no, the binding nature of the 18-2 decision means they will be legally obligated to pay a share of the league's defence costs if their own sponsors sue.

Nottingham Forest, owned by Evangelos Marinakis, were the only other club to vote against the changes. Reports indicate Forest's opposition was not out of solidarity with City, but rather because club officials felt they were not given enough time to consider the financial implications of an uncapped liability. Like City, Forest must still contribute their equal share if lawsuits materialise.

No cap on costs

There was no indication of a cap on the costs to which clubs could be exposed as a result of the change to the league's articles. There was also no broader discussion or questions raised about the City case, despite this being the first shareholders' meeting since the verdict was published on September 29.