Rangers secured a vital 2-1 away win at Motherwell on Saturday, keeping them within touching distance of Celtic at the top of the Premiership table. Despite firing 29 shots at goal at Fir Park, with 11 on target, some Hotline callers remain unconvinced, with one punter reiterating his belief that Derek McInnes is not the man to lead them back to title glory.
Fans unconvinced despite victory
Iain Morrison, Livingston, emailed in to say: "Another dreadful display from Rangers. As a Rangers fan, we’re in cuckoo land if we think we’ll win league, playing like we do. Score, then collapse. I still say it, McInnes is not the man. Some of his selections and substitutions are baffling. As for Dan Neil being stand-in captain, that sums up the manager we have."
In a similar vein, James Thomson added: "Just not good enough, this team has no chance winning this league."
Gordon Ferguson, Kilwinning, on the other hand is feeling a lot more positive, writing: "Rangers have found themselves a gem in Ryan Naderi. He has become the main man due to injuries but he keeps doing the business up front. He might well be the man to win Rangers' silverware in the upcoming cup final (against Hibs)."
Celtic fans react to Hogh treatment
Celtic diehard Charles Maxwell reckons the Rangers hype is over the top and hasn't ruled out Hearts challenging his team again after they put eight past Dundee without reply at Dens Park. He called in to say: "Well, well, well. It seems the best thing since sliced bread were had on toast for 87 minutes at a frosty Fir Park."
"There have been some pundits buttering up a bunch of outsiders these past few days. But after seeing the Jambos slicing through Dundee and Celtic spreading the ball about against St Mirren, it looks like Hearts might turn out to be the meat in the sandwich this season after all."
"It was plain to see rangers were not only stale after the international break, but also fell flat in the stamina steaks. Its plain to see Derek McInnes can't get his buns to rise and they are done after 60 minutes. Rangers fans should be thankful they are not in Europe. Any team with such low stamina levels would be torn apart on the continent."
Speaking of Hoops, Kenny Wilson, Moffat, was delighted to see Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain take centre stage in the 4-1 hammering of St Mirren. He stated: "A routine three points for the champions and a better performance playing some great stuff at times."
"Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain was rightly man of the match and I’ve said it before we’re a better team without Benjamin Nygren playing. Defence still doesn’t look solid enough and that needs to improve with a tough run of games coming up."
Stephen Mulhern, Dumbarton, added: "I approached Celtic Park yesterday in a somewhat apprehensive mood in the knowledge that our world class German internationalist Mika Baur would be absent from our lineup. However Oxlade Chamberlain fitted in seamlessly with a five star performance."
"The only downside was Martin O’Neill appalling treatment of Kasper Hogh I’m one hundred percent convinced he can still prove to be our fox in the box but with O’Neil having him warming the bench for the entire match it seems instead he’s put the final nails in his coffin."
Kick-off times debate continues
Meanwhile, the debate continues around the SPFL's choice of kick-off times in the Premiership. Scott Gowers, Edinburgh, argued: "A well known fact is it is harder to travel in an evening than it is earlier in the day before playing a football match. The excuses regarding TV coverage are pathetic. For years, Rangers were playing Europa League and Celtic were playing in the Champions League. Where were all Celtic's Saturday night games?"
"The thing that makes this deliberate making Rangers matches harder so obvious is the fact they have to travel to Easter Road on Monday 7th of December when there is absolutely no reason the match could not be played early and televised on Sunday 6th December. These intentional arrangements between the SPFL and Sky are very much against integrity within the sport."
Marink Reedijk came unstuck against Dundee United again as Hibs were thrashed 4-0 by Jim Goodwin's men on home turf, prompting Davy Cook, Edinburgh, to jest: "Hibs fans should maybe take up singing Christmas carols up Princes Street as there isn’t any sign of Sunshine on Leith getting belted out any time soon at Easter Road."