Mauricio Pochettino faces the toughest possible start as Manchester United manager, with the club in the relegation zone and just days to prepare his players for a trip to Anfield. Eight pundits have given their predictions, and only Gary Neville believes United will avoid defeat.
Neville's Lone Dissent
Neville, a former United defender and recent critic of the club, is the only pundit tipping a draw. "I just don’t think the defence is good enough, the defence will concede goals, I don’t care who the manager is," he said. "But I think it’ll be a draw. Probably." A point would lift United out of the drop zone on goal difference, ahead of 18th-placed Sunderland and 17th-placed Nottingham Forest.
Jamie Carragher, Neville's Sky Sports colleague, disagrees. Asked if United could prove Neville right, he joked: "They can, of course they can. They won’t, but of course they can." He added: "I think Liverpool will concede as well, but I’m going to go 3-1 [to Liverpool]."
Keane and Shearer Back Liverpool
Alan Shearer also expects a home win, citing United's defensive frailties. "I think Liverpool will win it. It depends on Mauricio Pochettino, though. Is he going to have enough time to actually get his ideas and his beliefs and his thoughts across?" he said. "I think he will eventually, but it will take longer than people think, and for that reason, I’ve got no faith defensively in Manchester United, and I think Liverpool will be too strong for them in both departments."
Roy Keane offered a brief prediction: "We’ll go 2-1, Liverpool." United's last trip to Anfield, in October 2025, ended in a win for the visitors.
Deeney and McCoist Expect Goals
Troy Deeney predicts a high-scoring affair, saying: "I'm going for 4-2 Liverpool. I think Liverpool will score early, I think Pochettino will then make his team press, go and get after the ball and it will make for a really open game. I think 4-2, I feel ultimately Liverpool and those forward players will just have too much."
Ally McCoist also backs Liverpool but acknowledges the new-manager effect. "Liverpool fans without any doubt would rather have been playing Manchester United with a previous manager. Nothing against Michael Carrick, but yeah, you know, the reason for me saying that is pretty obvious because nine times out of 10, you get a reaction from players when a new manager comes in," he said. "I fully expect the United players to react to the new manager, but I still fancy Liverpool."
Leiva and Sutton Predict Comfortable Win
Lucas Leiva, a former Liverpool midfielder, tips a 2-0 home win. "Eventually, United will come out of this, I’m sure. But Mauricio Pochettino will have a lot of work ahead of him," he said. "This fixture is something else; it’s one where it doesn’t matter about the form of both sides, the rivalry is so strong. It’s a big game which can go either way, but I‘d like to think Liverpool will win it 2-0."
Chris Sutton delivered the harshest warning in his BBC Sport column: "Pochettino will probably look to defend and play on the counter-attack, and they might get some chances that way, but Liverpool are going to win. The only question is how many they will score." He added: "Carrick began by beating Manchester City and Arsenal in his first two games in January. Pochettino might start by being on the wrong end of a pummelling."