Premier League seeks club backing over City sponsor legal threat
Premier League seeks club backing over City sponsor legal threat

The Premier League's five-person board of directors, led by chief executive Richard Masters, is asking clubs for legal protection should Manchester City's sponsors decide to sue them personally.

A league-wide meeting on Thursday will reportedly see the board make a request for clubs to cover their legal expenses, potentially worth billions of pounds, if a corporate defamation case is brought against them.

Background to the dispute

It's been almost two months since an independent commission appointed by the Premier League found City guilty of artificially inflating the club's revenue by £900million through what it described as 'sham' contracts with sponsors between 2008 and 2019. Masters added in a damning statement that City - who were charged in February 2023 but deny any wrongdoing and have appealed the verdict - had 'systematically broken Premier League rules for nearly a decade'.

City's stadium and front-of-shirt sponsor, Etihad Airways, responded within 24 hours by saying that it was considering legal action against the Premier League, with the airline making several complaints. Meanwhile, fellow sponsors Etisalat - a telecommunications company worth more than £40bn - said on Monday that it viewed the findings related to Etisalat as 'entirely false and defamatory', and was considering its legal options.

Board seeks indemnity

The Premier League has come to realise that its board - comprised of Masters, Alison Brittain, Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC - is not equipped with indemnity from legal action from a third party, such as one of the sponsors. A report from the Times claims that league chiefs will seek to change that at Thursday's planned meeting with all 20 clubs in London.

It's explained that the change would see Premier League clubs collectively pay for legal expenses and any damages that could follow successful legal action from one of City's principal sponsors or any other third party. The document in question - which was sent to clubs for consideration ahead of the meeting - makes no mention of City, the club's sponsors or the 115 charges case.

Potential legal exposure

Despite that, insiders reportedly view it as a response to Etihad's legal threat. Article 35 of the Premier League's articles of association currently states that a director's legal expenses will only be reimbursed if they win a case.

Sponsors could also opt to take action outside of the UK, with corporate defamation claims in the United States known to have risen above the billion-pound mark. There, both sides are required to pay their own legal fees irrespective of the outcome.

The Premier League declined to comment when contacted by Mirror Football.