Mauricio Pochettino has finally been appointed Manchester United manager, two years after the club's drawn-out public flirtation with the Argentine almost culminated in him landing the job he craved. Pochettino stepped out at Carrington earlier this week to begin his tenure.
Two-Year Courtship
After being pipped to the post by Erik ten Hag two years prior, Pochettino was sounded out about replacing the Dutchman in the summer of 2024. Unlike previous courtships that had been played out in the public eye, this approach was very much the opposite. Pochettino had not long left Chelsea, while Ten Hag, though heavily scrutinised, was still officially in his post as manager.
In the end, Ineos and Pochettino decided against taking things further. It is understood that United felt Pochettino was still bruised by the year he spent in charge at Chelsea; a body of work which has only got better with age.
Ready for the Challenge
Though he has had to wait a big longer, Pochettino has now been deemed ready and rejuvenated to a point where he is suitable to tackle the gargantuan task of rehabilitating a Manchester United side who have endured their worst start to a season in 40 years.
Getting to this point has not been without its complications, though through no fault of Pochettino's own. On paper, the job he did at Chelsea was not dissatisfactory; the Argentine guided Chelsea to a sixth-place finish, which represented a commendable recovery considering the turbulent start to his reign.
During his time at the helm, Pochettino had to juggle an inflated squad assembled for grand outlays in an environment where the expectations were perhaps even grander.
USMNT Rejuvenation
The manner of his exit, which was mutually agreed with the Blues' ownership, was swift. It was no surprise, either, given the rumblings of discontent between Pochettino and the club hierarchy which had been present for months. That, coupled with a similarly taxing but rewarding spell at Paris Saint-Germain which culminated in Pochettino's first major honours as a manager, was enough to put United off the idea of finally giving Pochettino the keys to the Old Trafford kingdom.
There were no such reservations, however, at U.S. Soccer. Pochettino was exactly the type of high-profile coach they craved ahead of a much anticipated home World Cup. His decision to embark on an unexpected career arc with the United States men's national team, following talks with former Southampton ally Matt Crocker in his role as technical director of the U.S. Soccer Federation, appears to have paid dividends.
Pochettino's stint in America has re-energised a coach who long appeared to have the required charisma and drive to manage in the figurehead role of a footballing institution like Manchester United. That is despite the fact that the USMNT's exploits at the World Cup, much like Pochettino's stints at Chelsea and PSG, were steady rather than spectacular.
Cultural Fit and Future
Success at a home World Cup was always the ultimate goal; a prize which would trump anything that preceded it. But their campaign was preceded by a turbulent 2025 which saw Pochettino's credentials questioned. The team regrouped and started the tournament in spectacular fashion, romping to a 4-1 victory in the opener over Paraguay. That dazzling show in Los Angeles was followed up by the USMNT's first victory in a World Cup knockout game since 2002. Pochettino's men rode the crest of a wave until it crashed in the last 16, their journey coming full circle with a bludgeoning 4-1 defeat at the hands of Belgium.
Pochettino's impact in the role transcended that last 16 finish and he was subsequently offered an extension. With the twinkle back in his eye and whispers of a Premier League return, the decision to extend until 2030 raised eyebrows. But unlike at PSG and Chelsea, Pochettino had unearthed the right cultural fit for the first time since those halcyon days at Tottenham.
JT Batson, the chief executive of U.S. Soccer, expressed how important that element had been when they decided to offer Pochettino the job back in 2024. Speaking to The Athletic prior to the World Cup, he said: “Just because someone is a big name, doesn’t mean they’re the right fit for what you’re trying to do.”
“(The coach) needed to be a good cultural fit, a good strategic fit for U.S. Soccer, as well as for the men’s national team. That was, first and foremost, the most important thing.”
Though not the expected - or orthodox - environment for Pochettino to rediscover his mojo, Manchester United stand to benefit from his odyssey across the Atlantic. Just as he leaves U.S. Soccer in an emboldened position, Pochettino looks, sounds and feels re-energised.
The most obvious threat to his renaissance is the fact that he is once again about to embark into the pressure cooker of an elite club. But this is also the club, and the job, that Pochettino has long wanted. Manchester United feel he is ready for it. Crucially, suggestions that he instructed his representatives to make United aware of the release clause in his USMNT contract would indicate he feels he is, too.
That he referenced culture in his first message to supporters is telling. Building it from the beleaguered foundations inherited is another matter altogether. But Pochettino has done it before, famously on these shores, and after experiencing it with the US, there is reason enough to suggest he can do it once again.