Newcastle right to skip Trafford, Hornicek can be Premier League best
Newcastle right to skip Trafford, Hornicek can be top keeper

Newcastle United did not make a mistake by not trying to sign James Trafford for a third successive transfer window, according to former Liverpool, Portsmouth and England goalkeeper David James, who believes Lukas Hornicek has an 'opportunity' to become one of the Premier League's top goalkeepers.

Trafford saga and Hornicek arrival

Newcastle had twice tried to sign Trafford under Eddie Howe in both the summers of 2024 and 2025 and had agreed a fee with Burnley last year to sign the England international. But Manchester City exercised their matching rights option that was inserted when they sold Trafford to Burnley two years before that, and he had looked set to become their number one goalkeeper.

However, after just three matches in the starting XI, Pep Guardiola's side signed Gianluigi Donnarumma from PSG and Trafford found himself playing second choice. As such, the 24-year-old was keen to move on in the search of regular football and there was an expectation that Newcastle would return to the market to try and sign him.

But Newcastle passed up on that opportunity and he joined Leeds United instead, with his performances so far at Elland Road seeing him emerge as a serious challenge to Jordan Pickford's position as England number one. The Magpies opted to move for Czechia international Lukas Hornicek instead, paying £25.7million to prise him away from Portuguese side Braga, and he has quickly established himself as the club's new number one goalkeeper.

James backs Hornicek

James has been seriously impressed with Hornicek and, as such, feels Newcastle have not paid any price for missing out on a goalkeeper of Trafford's quality.

"No, I don't think they did. I think Hornicek is a very capable goalkeeper," James told Chronicle Live, on behalf of LiveFootballTickets. "Again, he's 24 years old. The idea that a 24-year-old is the finished article is wrong. You're never the finished article at that age. Whether you're the finished article at 34 is another question. There's so much room for development."

"From what I've seen of him, it goes back to the manager and the coach. You do what you need to do in preparation and training, get the best out of him and improve the areas that need improvement. Then you've got a more than capable goalkeeper. I don't think James Trafford would be the difference between Newcastle's position now with either James or Hornicek in goal."

"James Trafford is doing exceptionally well at Leeds, but Leeds were doing exceptionally well last season anyway. It's not as though he's transformed that side; he's enhanced it, granted. But I think with Hornicek at Newcastle, there's an opportunity to have one of the top goalkeepers in the Premier League."

Pope's situation

Hornicek's arrival, as well as the acquisition of France under-21 international goalkeeper Ewen Jaouen, has seen Nick Pope plummet down the goalkeeping pecking order from first choice to third choice. Having been one of Newcastle's best goalkeepers of the 21st century, the England international's form dipped last season and the club, ultimately, decided they wanted to move forward with a goalkeeper who was more proficient with his feet.

Pope has been linked with a move to Bayern Munich next summer and with his contract at St James' Park set to expire at the end of the season, James feels there are still opportunities at a high level for the 34-year-old.

"I think a lot of it comes down to the injury issues," James added when asked about Pope's situation. "I had that situation myself towards the end of my career. I'm not saying Nick is at the end of his career, but I started getting injured towards the end of mine. As I've said before, when you need to work on certain aspects of your game, injury is obviously going to hamper that. He's still young enough. When I say young enough, I think about my own career, and I'd like to think my best years were when I was 36 to 38. So there's plenty of time."

"But again, it has to be done on the training field to get yourself into a position where, when you do play, your best form comes out. Then you give the manager the headache of deciding who to play. It's not just a cliché. I like Hornicek. I think he's going to be top-drawer, but Nick Pope at his best was producing clean sheets for Newcastle left, right and centre. So there's still an opportunity for Nick."