Motherwell chief: Scotland youth drain is a 'massive issue'
Motherwell chief: Scotland youth drain is a 'massive issue'

Motherwell chief executive Brian Caldwell has described the loss of Scotland's best young players to clubs in England as a "massive issue" and is urging clubs to back a proposed scholarship scheme to stem the flow.

Statistics show that 66 Scottish teenagers moved to English clubs between 2021 and 2026, up from 35 between 2012 and 2020, with 13 leaving in the first seven months of 2026 alone. Caldwell argues this is driving the decline of homegrown players emerging within the Scottish Premiership.

Fewer than four per cent of minutes

Caldwell insists this is the hard truth behind the SFA's committee report, which found that fewer than four per cent of minutes were played by Scottish players aged 21 or younger last season.

He said: "Ten years ago there was a compensation system for clubs who were investing money in their academies. They got compensation for a young player if they moved to another club within Scotland.

"Then it changed so that other clubs domestically could cherry pick the best young players and only have to pay compensation if they turned professional."

Pathways to first-team football

Caldwell pointed to examples such as John McGinn, who played almost 100 games for St Mirren before moving to Hibs as a 20-year-old, and Lennon Miller, who opted to stay at Motherwell for first-team opportunities aged 16 and 17.

He said: "At the moment there is no deterrent for other clubs to take the best young players away from other academies up and down the country. The issue is that a lot of these clubs don't have a pathway to first-team football compared with the clubs they are taking these young players from."

Motherwell have lost five players in the last two-and-a-half years to other academies. One went to England and four to other Scottish clubs. Caldwell said: "A little compensation was paid by the club down south but we received no money for the other four players. We invested in these boys from the age of eight-years-old to 14 and 15.

"It's become a try-before-you-buy for the bigger clubs and it's a massive issue for our game."

Scholarship scheme proposal

Caldwell is pushing for a scholarship system similar to the one in place in England, which would guarantee young players a two-year apprenticeship for full-time football and prevent moves unless compensation is agreed.

He said: "We are pushing for scholarship system similar to the one in place down south. If you have an exceptional talent within your academy then you can commit to a scholarship for them which kicks in when they leave school. It guarantees them a two-year apprenticeship for full-time football.

"That safeguards clubs as a young player cannot move unless compensation is agreed. It is something I've been banging on about and it needs to happen in Scottish football. The SFA are looking at how we can bring this in."

Caldwell noted that the Old Firm are also losing players to England for very little compensation, adding: "A scholarship arrangement could really change the dial for Scottish clubs. UEFA regard it as a professional contract so it would stop English clubs taking our best for next to nothing. Both clubs would have to agree a fee."

Academy funding concerns

Caldwell also warned that the removal of an SFA grant could make clubs think twice about the logic of having academies. He said this is the last year of receiving the £125,000 grant given to clubs, and there will be consequences.

He said: "Clubs need to look at what they are investing in if they are losing their best young players for nothing."