Paul Ince has criticised Manchester United's dressing room, blaming a culture issue for the team's poor form. The former United midfielder, who won two league titles under Sir Alex Ferguson, named several current squad members he believes are not up to standard, including two recent arrivals.
Ince singles out six players
Summer signings Youri Tielemans and Andrey Santos were among those criticised by Ince. Perennially injured defenders Matthijs de Ligt and Luke Shaw were also named, while the fitness records of Lisandro Martinez and Benjamin Sesko came under scrutiny.
New head coach Mauricio Pochettino will take charge of his first United game this weekend with the team in the relegation zone. Pochettino has spoken about culture being key, but Ince feels the problems run deep.
Culture and leadership concerns
“Nowadays, you've got players who just play for Man United, not Man United players,” Ince told Express Sport. “And it's a culture trend. You look at our team in the 90s, the majority of us were probably British. It was British, Swedish, Norway, that type of stuff. Now you've got such a combination of different nationalities, which makes it harder to build a culture in the changing rooms. The cultural thing is a massive thing.
“And I think we're seeing a lot of it now, where players are coming out and speaking about clubs, speaking about owners, speaking about tactics. That would never, never happen in Fergie's day. One, the changing room probably wouldn't allow that to happen. You'd be ostracised if you did that and you would never play for Fergie again.
“So there seems to be this kind of way that players think they can come out and start talking about the manager's tactics and criticising the club and [saying] we should be doing this and doing that. You wouldn't get away with it, so the standards have obviously completely changed.
“I've seen it as a manager and I've experienced it where you get little cliques. You get some people speak French, some people speak Spanish, and they all kind of stick together. I think that's an issue when you're trying to build a culture in the changing room.”
Ince suggested the current squad lacks leaders and role models, a marked change from his own time at Old Trafford when players like Bryan Robson, Roy Keane and Eric Cantona set an example. Captain Bruno Fernandes publicly criticised the club after a recent defeat away to Como, and Lisandro Martinez criticised the hierarchy after a summer in which United lost ground on their rivals.
Recruitment under fire
Ince believes United wasted money on Tielemans and Santos. He insisted Pochettino needs backing in the transfer market if things are to change.
“Poch has got bags of experience. I don't think he'll be fazed by coming to Old Trafford,” Ince added. “I think he needs at least three transfer windows. I think the back four needs to be changed. Midfield I think they've got that wrong. They need to probably find a number nine who can score goals.
“So it's a lot of work to be done, and it's just a case of if he's got carte blanche on doing all that, because the recruitment in the last four or five years hasn't been great. They brought in [Matthijs] De Ligt, who's never fit. Martinez, who's never fit.
“The reason why Man United were so great over these years was because the players played 40 games a season. There was no playing two and being out for three months.
“As well as looking at top top players, you've got to look at players who can play every week. And this is the problem, they've wasted so much money.
“Why would Bayern Munich want to get rid of De Ligt? There must be a reason. It's chasing players just for the sake of the name, not based on can they perform week in and week out?”
He added: “You can go on about six, seven, eight players. They bought Santos for 50 million pounds. Why buy Santos?
“You've got Kobbie Mainoo who's a young midfield player, trying to develop at Manchester United? Why would you go and spend £50million on someone of the same type?
“You get Tielemans, £30m. So you've basically wasted £80m where you could have got a striker, you could have got two centre halves.
“They're not making the right decisions. So when you kind of think about changing it and the time it's going to change, you're talking another two years. You're talking about another three or four transfer windows.
“They haven't got a proper centre forward. Sesko's come off the bench last year and scored some important goals. doesn't play, injured.
“There's a problem with all these players, something's not right when these players keep getting injured long-term. We know Luke Shaw's done it all his career but these players who they keep buying, they keep getting injured.
“It can't be right, and this is why you probably don't see that consistency. So if I'm looking at Poch now, I hope he's got carte blanche on bringing the players in and the right players, and not the hierarchy because they're making too many poor decisions and you're seeing it in the form of Manchester United.”