Sir Alex Ferguson once identified Rio Ferdinand and Patrice Evra as key contributors to his "worst ever day" as Manchester United manager. The legendary Scot, who led the club from 1986 to 2013, enjoyed a period of dominance that included 13 Premier League titles, 19 domestic cups and two Champions League triumphs. Yet that era also contained crushing lows, and the 84-year-old has pointed to one match above all others.
The 6-1 defeat that shook Old Trafford
The lowest point, in Ferguson's view, came on October 23, 2011, when Manchester United suffered a 6-1 home defeat to fierce rivals Manchester City. City had spent most of their Premier League history in United's shadow until 2008, when the Abu Dhabi United Group took over the club and began spending heavily. Ferguson had playfully dismissed City as United's "noisy neighbours," but the result proved otherwise.
City took the lead through Mario Balotelli's first-half opener. Two minutes after the break, Jonny Evans was shown a red card by referee Mark Clattenburg for bringing down Balotelli on the edge of the area as the last man, denying a goalscoring opportunity. That dismissal left United with 10 men and opened the floodgates.
Ferguson's criticism of his defenders
Balotelli scored his second with 30 minutes remaining, and Sergio Aguero added another nine minutes later. Darren Fletcher pulled one back to make it 3-1 with less than two minutes of normal time left, but Edin Dzeko scored twice either side of stoppage time and David Silva also found the net at the death.
Reflecting on the match, Ferguson admitted it was his worst day in management and singled out Ferdinand and Evra for their part in the defensive collapse. He said: "It was a bad day, there is no doubt about that; it was my worst ever day."
"Jonny Evans's sending off was a killer for us. With 10 men, we kept attacking - it was crazy football and ended up being an embarrassment. We should have just said, 'We've had our day.' I believe you shouldn't bring down a man on the edge of the box. Evans is young, but he should let Balotelli go through and see what he can do. I thought with the experience we've got - Rio Ferdinand, Patrice Evra - they would have defended more, but we just kept attacking. Sometimes there has to be common sense about it. It was a bad day. I can't believe the scoreline. Even as a player, I don't think I ever lost 6-1. That's a challenge for me too."
City's title triumph that season
City went on to win the Premier League title that season on goal difference, sealed by Aguero's iconic stoppage-time strike in a 3-2 win over QPR on the final day of the 2011/12 campaign. That victory marked the start of a new era of dominance in Manchester, this time based at the Etihad Stadium.