UK denies EU summit will force budget payments or marmalade relabel
UK denies EU summit will force budget payments or relabels

The UK government has released a factsheet insisting British taxpayers will not pay millions into the EU budget and that marmalade will not be relabelled, ahead of a UK-EU summit in Brussels on Friday.

The Cabinet Office document addresses concerns about closer ties with the bloc, including claims about sauce sachets, smoky flavours in crisps, and the labelling of British marmalade. It states that sauce sachets will not be banned and that British marmalade will not be re-labelled "citrus marmalade" under plans for closer relations.

Government answers key questions

One question in the factsheet asks whether British taxpayers will have to pay millions of pounds into the EU budget. The answer says: "No. There will be nothing in the UK Government’s Sanitary & Phytosanitary (SPS), Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) and Youth Experience Scheme (YES) deals that will require UK taxpayers to pay into the EU budget. As is standard in international agreements, the UK Government has always been clear that both sides will pay proportionate contributions for the running costs associated with the functioning and administration of the agreement (such as shared IT systems and databases). This is different from paying into the EU’s budget."

The document also insists it is inaccurate that smoky flavours in crisps, sauces and soups will be banned. It says: "This is inaccurate. Smoky flavours in crisps, sauces, and soups will remain on UK supermarket shelves. Most British crisp makers adapted their recipes years ago in order to continue selling into Europe."

Marmalade and sachet claims addressed

Reports earlier this year suggested British marmalade would need to be rebranded, a claim the government says is wrong. The document says: "British marmalade will not need to be relabelled, as most British marmalade brands on supermarket shelves already meet European labelling rules, so they can sell into Europe."

The government also said there will be no ban on single-serve sachets of ketchup, mayonnaise, sugar, salt, oil and vinegar.

Political reaction and small boats

Shadow Cabinet Office Minister Mike Wood criticised the factsheet, saying: "This latest propaganda from the Government about its EU reset is highly disingenuous. It totally neglects the costs of the Erasmus scheme and other EU programmes which we know for a fact will cost British taxpayers cash. And it contradicts the Government’s own statements to Parliament about regulatory alignment. Either Labour are wilfully misleading the public or they are in complete confusion about the deal they are supposed to be negotiating. Either way, Britain is losing out."

The Cabinet Office document repeats the government's position that Brexit has contributed to small boat crossings, blaming a lack of returns agreements and less intelligence sharing. The paper states: "While leaving the EU is not the sole cause of small boat crossings, the UK Government’s view is that leaving made tackling the issue harder by reducing access to intelligence and returns mechanisms. Leaving the European Union reduced the UK’s access to shared EU security information on those crossing the Channel, removed existing mechanisms to return migrants, and meant the UK has had to focus on negotiating new bilateral agreements—including with France, Belgium, and Germany. No one is saying leaving the EU is the sole reason behind small boat crossings, and the Prime Minister has been clear that this is not an excuse to avoid taking the necessary action to secure and restore control to the UK’s borders."