Miliband vs Burnham: Rosebank Oilfield Decision Sparks Labour Split
Rosebank Oilfield Decision Sparks Labour Split

Ed Miliband is intensifying pressure on Prime Minister Andy Burnham over the future of the Rosebank oilfield, a decision that threatens to split the Labour Party and damage Burnham's leadership.

Miliband, now Foreign Secretary, has previously branded drilling at Rosebank as "climate vandalism" and is reportedly working behind the scenes to block the project. He has been joined by Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, Miliband's left-wing protégé, who is also opposed to the development.

The Rosebank Decision

The Rosebank oilfield's output would mostly be sold overseas rather than used domestically, but it would still generate jobs and tax revenues, boost the balance of payments and support the pound. Oil industry sources estimate its value at £28.7bn, money that could be used to bring down bills.

The cabinet is split on the issue. Chancellor John Healey is keen to press ahead, and Burnham is expected to favour approval as well. However, Miliband and Fahnbulleh are dead against it, and the pair have been accused of stirring up a backbench revolt against the plan.

Backbench Rebellion

Whipping up Labour backbenchers is not difficult, as they have been in a constant state of rebellion since Keir Starmer became PM. But this is the most serious one Burnham has faced, with 75 MPs signing a private letter warning him that Rosebank won't reduce energy bills. Some estimate that rebel numbers could hit 200.

Burnham faces a hellish decision. After the summer the country has had, only a die-hard climate change denialist can claim fossil fuels aren't doing damage. The world still runs on oil, so the transition is not complete, and given the miserable state of the nation's finances, £28.7bn is not to be sniffed at.

Political Fallout

Burnham will mostly be looking at the politics. He is desperate to unite the left and win voters back from Zack Polanski's Green Party. If Rosebank gets the go-ahead, eco-minded leftists will throw Miliband's "climate vandalism" accusation straight back in Burnham's face.

Miliband has made it clear he won't resign from his cabinet job if Rosebank gets the go-ahead, but behind the scenes he is doing everything he can to make sure it doesn't. Fahnbulleh also has her career to think of, as she doesn't want climate vandalism on her CV.

Burnham's reputation is on the line. If he caves and blocks Rosebank, he will look weak. If he gives it the thumbs up, the left will be in revolt and Polanski will make a comeback. Burnham struggles to make decisions at the best of times, and this one must be agony, but he has to make it, and he is going to take a beating either way.