Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband repeatedly refused to name a single supermarket item that will become cheaper under Prime Minister Andy Burnham's new EU food and drink trade deal, during an interview with BBC host Laura Kuenssberg.
The deal, agreed between Mr Burnham and EU officials, is designed to remove red tape on exports of food and drink to EU nations. It was welcomed by British manufacturers, but it will require EU laws to be enforced across the UK once again.
Interview clash over price promises
Ms Kuenssberg asked Mr Miliband: "Can you tell us one item where you're sure that prices definitely will go down?"
Mr Miliband responded: "I'm not going to pick out items or pick out a number. What I am going to say to you is don't take my word for it, take the word of all the retailers, and you can look at all of the quotes from every single major retailer and supermarket as far as I can tell."
Ms Kuenssberg hit back, noting that the British Retail Consortium, which represents all of them, had said: "This might reduce pressure on our trading costs. It is unlikely to have any impact on prices in the near future." She added: "The Prime Minister and you are repeatedly telling people prices are going to come down in the shops. The people who run the shops as a group are saying that might not come to pass."
The Labour heavyweight insisted: "I'm saying it's reducing downward pressure on prices, and it's billions of pounds of costs, and what the retailers are all saying, is it will reduce downward pressure on prices."
Government defends deal
Mr Miliband also denied Labour was misleading the public over food prices. He pointed to statements from Morrisons, the Co-op and Marks & Spencer, saying all of the food retailers had welcomed the deal and said it would apply downward pressure on prices.
He added: "Now, we're not putting a number on that, but there is a truth here, which is that since Brexit, our exports have fallen by 20%. Crucially, and this is the point that I noticed the retailers were making today—it will reduce the costs that the retailers face."
The Government will present legislation to Parliament next week bringing EU regulations governing food and drink back into force. The Prime Minister said Treasury analysis suggested the deal would add up to 0.5% to gross domestic product by 2040, cut costs for business and help with "the cost of the weekly shop".
Conservatives vow to repeal
Deputy Conservative leader Alex Burghart said his party would "certainly repeal this deal" if they form a government. Speaking on Sky News's Sunday Morning With Michael Gove programme, he said: "I think that there are some businesses that for whom this will certainly make life easier. There are certainly a lot more businesses for whom it will make life worse and I don't believe for a moment that these very small changes, or these very small changes in cost, are actually going to filter their way through to consumers at a time when the Government has policies that are making the cost of energy and electricity much higher."
He added: "I don't think we'll ever see cheaper food as a result of this." Asked if the Conservatives would repeal everything in the deal, he said: "We will certainly repeal this deal." Asked how much that would cost, he said: "I think it will actually end up saving people money."
Mr Burghart criticised the decision to reopen the Brexit issue, saying: "I wish we weren't having to do this, Michael. I wish that Andy Burnham had chose not to reopen the Brexit issue. I think there was no need to do so." He dismissed the government's GDP forecast, saying: "You will know as well as me that when you hear government ministers talk about very small changes in GDP over the very long-term, they're talking out of their posterior."
He concluded: "They should have left this alone. Instead, they're creating a bad deal which will be expensive for the UK, which will put British business and British farmers in jeopardy in the medium term, and so of course we can't stand by it."