Andy Burnham's plans to ease the cost-of-living crisis, solve the social care problem, build hundreds of thousands of council houses, nationalise water, energy and rail, hike the £12,570 personal allowance and cut the welfare bill are based on fantasy rather than reality, according to a critical assessment. The measures will cost a fortune, do less than promised and make everything worse, the argument goes, with evidence already emerging.
Jobs and welfare plans under fire
Last night, Burnham set out plans to cut the benefits bill by getting more people into work. But it is Labour's own £25billion jobs tax that is the problem, the critic argues. Since former chancellor Rachel Reeves made it more expensive for businesses to take people on, hiring has collapsed.
Payrolled jobs plunged by 111,000 in the year to August, while vacancies slumped to their lowest level since 2021. Housing Secretary Angela Rayner's workers' rights reforms have made things worse, by making small firms terrified to hire in case they end up at the sharp end of an employment tribunal.
First, Labour made it harder for businesses to employ people, now it will blow a staggering £6billion subsidising 200,000 jobs they might otherwise have created if Reeves hadn't interfered. Even Alan Milburn, the man behind the reforms, admits they won't save taxpayers a penny for a whole decade. Rebel Labour MPs are gearing up to block them anyway, just in case they do.
Housing and nationalisation questioned
The same fantasy runs through housing. Burnham promises a £39billion council housebuilding programme, the biggest since the post-war period. Before him, Keir Starmer promised 1.5 million homes this Parliament. Even Angela Rayner has conceded the target will be missed, and Burnham is doubling down on a failed idea. Those homes will never happen, the critic says, with perhaps only a few thousand delivered.
Then there is nationalisation. Taking the railways, water and energy into public control is supposed to make services better and cheaper. The reality of renationalisation is proving to be very different to Burnham's fantasy version. South Western Rail suffered a 50% spike in cancellations after Labour nationalised it, while Greater Anglia and c2c have also seen a rise in delays.
The railways were originally nationalised because government lacked the cash to provide a decent service. Now they will be starved of investment all over again. Burnham is promising the glories of the re-branded Great British Railways, but instead the country is heading back to disastrous British Rail.
Costly quangos and devolution
Burnham's belief that the state can do everything better means more and more costly quangos. To take just one example, Ed Miliband's £24billion Great British Energy has recorded a £14.1m loss in its first year and hasn't shaved a penny off energy bills. The bet is it never will, despite having £8.3billion of public money behind it.
Burnham wants to push power away from Westminster, but devolution means more politicians, administrators and pen-pushers. The last thing Britain needs is another layer of meddling bureaucrats, but that is what is coming.
Burnham's uncosted plan to unfreeze the £12,570 personal allowance has already succumbed to reality. It could cost £8.4billion a year that is not available. The freeze will continue to 2031, and possibly beyond.
Every politician has their dreams, but they have to be rooted in reality. Burnham keeps announcing grand solutions without explaining how they'll work, what they'll achieve or how they can be afforded. The only thing that is real is the bill, and it will be huge.