Andy Burnham's approach to Europe is drawing comparisons to Labour's historical tactics of promising future savings in exchange for immediate funding, a strategy critics say is both cynical and costly.
Milburn's Youth Unemployment Plan Under Fire
This week, former health secretary Alan Milburn published his report on youth unemployment, calling for a "complete reset" on state policy towards young people not in employment, education, or training, known as NEETs, of whom there are 980,000 in Britain. Milburn proposed an immediate upfront payment of at least £500 million, plus an annual rise of almost £6 billion in overall social security spending, in exchange for a potential saving of just £200 million a year by 2036.
Critics argue this approach is exactly what Britain does not need, especially with the welfare bill reaching £337 billion this year. The plan has been praised for its boldness, but some see it as a repeat of past mistakes, echoing Frank Field's unaffordable welfare blueprint that was ultimately shelved.
Burnham's EU Stance Contradicts Pledge
Burnham, who became Labour leader last summer, previously stated in the Makerfield by-election that he did not want to "reopen" the question of Britain's EU membership. However, his current actions, including a deal on food standards and free movement for young people, suggest otherwise. The latest poll shows 63% of the public supports rejoin, but the political landscape remains volatile, and the EU faces its own challenges with rising right-wing parties in Germany and France.
The terms for Britain's re-entry are likely to be tough, with no opt-outs on the single currency or Schengen, and no return to any rebate. Burnham's failure to abide by his Makerfield pledge could be a significant political risk.
Public Sector 'Underfunding' Narrative Questioned
The narrative of public sector underfunding is also being challenged. The public workforce is larger than ever, with the civil service employing over 550,000 people, up from 384,000 ten years ago. Police numbers in England and Wales now stand at 146,000, compared to just 66,000 in 1955, yet crime is higher. This suggests that inefficiencies and over-staffing, rather than a lack of resources, may be the real issue.
The contrast is stark when considering that the British Empire in India was run by just 1,200 officials, while the Colonial Office in London had only 62 staff. Today, the Ministry of Defence employs 89 communications officers alone, highlighting potential waste in the public sector.