Burnham's EU gamble: high stakes as Brexit battle lines drawn
Burnham's EU gamble: high stakes as Brexit battle lines drawn

Andy Burnham heads to Brussels this week as battle lines are drawn once again on Brexit. At an EU-UK summit on Friday, the Prime Minister hopes to secure agreements to smooth post-Brexit trade and to establish a youth experience programme allowing young people to move between the UK and EU for limited periods.

These deals, long in the making, could bring real positives for Britain. But the question gripping Westminster and beyond is what the PM's wider plan on Europe is. Mr Burnham smashed Labour's Brexit taboo in September with a promise to look at the UK's future relationship with the bloc, a decade on from the referendum.

PM's honest conversation on Europe

The Prime Minister says he wants to have an honest conversation with the public about how the status quo isn't working. Downing Street insiders echo this, insisting he doesn't have a secret end goal and will be led by the public.

A No10 source said: "It's important to him because he thinks it's [Brexit] made people worse off. As he told Cabinet last week, if you want to get growth going then it's an obvious lever to pull."

Bringing the UK closer to Europe could bring huge benefits, particularly for the economy, as well as diplomatically as the US becomes an increasingly unreliable ally. Polls suggest the public agrees with Mr Burnham that the country has ended up in an "Emperor's new clothes" situation.

Old Brexit tensions resurface

Old Brexit tensions will make a genuinely open conversation difficult. A familiar cast of characters is coming out of the woodwork, ready to fight the old war. Vote Leave has a new outfit, Stay Out, which has returned to its old playbook with a claim that re-joining the EU would cost the UK £750m a week. Leave.EU, a separate group run by Ukip figures, is gearing up for a return. Ex-Tory PMs Boris Johnson and David Cameron have also weighed in in recent days.

There is unease among Labour MPs, some trade unions and in the Cabinet about restarting the debate. Some critics frame Burnham's approach as an attempt to speak to Labour, but the party is far from united on Brexit. Research by More in Common at the weekend showed 62% of Labour MPs represent constituencies that backed Leave in 2016, including a number of Cabinet ministers.

Divisive issue remains

Brexit remains incredibly divisive, partly because it meant different things to different people. The EU has also changed significantly in the last decade, but old wounds remain despite efforts by Keir Starmer's government to reset the relationship.

So much will depend on what is actually on the table, and how deftly Mr Burnham can make his arguments. He has shown he has the political skill and the courage to confront difficult issues like social care and reforming the pensions triple lock.

The 2016 referendum unleashed something that Brexiteers struggled to control. In a telling observation, Mr Johnson warned Mr Burnham against "wasting his premiership" on Europe. The risk for the PM is that the debate on Europe overshadows everything else he's trying to do, but if he can navigate a better relationship and bring the country with him, then it will be worth it.