Andy Burnham has been accused of heaping “punishment” on Britain’s farmers amid claims his deal with the European Union could cost the country up to £3billion a year. Nigel Farage vowed that repealing the “pernicious deal” would be a priority for a Reform UK Government and Leader of the Opposition Kemi Badenoch blasted Mr Burnham for wanting to “hand Brussels the rulebook for British farming”.
Their condemnations of the deal unveiled on Friday came as newly-launched campaign group Stay Out warned that the measures agreed at the Brussels summit “could cost the public finances up to £2.21billion a year, with businesses facing a further £763million a year in new costs”.
Conservative and Reform UK criticism
The Conservative leader gave a damning verdict on the agreement which will see most of the checks of British food exports scrapped in return for the UK abiding by a host of EU regulations. Her warning came as a senior ally of the Prime Minister briefed the Times that Mr Burnham believes “deeply” that the United Kingdom should rejoin the EU.
Mr Farage told the Sunday Express it is “rage-inducing” to see an “unelected” prime minister “trampling on the largest democratic exercise ever seen in Britain, while selling us this stitch-up”. He said: “The whole thing is deeply immoral,” adding: “One of the first priorities of a Reform UK government will be to repeal this pernicious deal. Not just to honour the democratic mandate which it so heinously attacks, and to preserve the idea that a vote is more than just a means to power.”
Impact on farmers
Mr Burnham has described the full deal – which includes provisions for emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme – as a “£17bn boost to the British economy” but major questions remain about the impact on UK agriculture.
Mrs Badenoch highlighted the distress Britain’s farming communities have experienced since Labour took power. Then-Chancellor Rachel Reeves’s plans to force more farming families to pay inheritance tax triggered giant protests before being watered down. She told the Sunday Express: “How much more does Labour think British farmers can take? First they hit them with the family farm tax. Now Andy Burnham wants to hand Brussels the rulebook for British farming. He clearly hasn’t got a clue about rural life or the pressures farmers are under. We already have some of the highest food standards in the world. Why on earth should a British farmer who doesn’t sell a single thing to Europe have to follow rules made in Brussels? It’s ludicrous.”
The Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) warned British food producers could face new compliance costs as a result of the deal. It is also concerned it could put “British innovation at risk” when it comes to gene-editing and cultivated meat. The think tank wants the Government to publish a full impact assessment before a parliamentary vote with only firms selling to the EU required to follow EU rules. Dr Valentin Boboc, chief economist at the IEA, said: “Cutting paperwork for exporters is worth doing, but this deal pays for it by placing all British food production under rules made in Brussels, on which Britain has no vote.”
Government response
Conservative Shadow Chancellor Andrew Griffith accused Mr Burnham of “putting Brussels ahead of Britain”. And Oliver Lewis, chairman of Stay Out, said: “Having already hammered farmers with its family farm tax raid, Andy Burnham is now ready to hand their future to Brussels… Every concession brings rejoining closer, and the Prime Minister should be putting British farmers and families first, not Brussels.”
A Government source hit back at Stay Out’s warning the EU deal would come with a price tag of up to £3billion a year, dismissing it as a “dodgy” claim. “The status quo is not working because Brexit has done more harm than good,” the source said. “Our deal will add £17billion a year to our economy, by cutting costs for business, helping with the cost of the weekly shop and creating opportunities for young people.” A Government spokesperson said the food and drink element of the deal “could add up to £5.1bn to the UK economy, strengthening food supply chains, reducing costs for businesses and helping put downward pressure on food price inflation”.
There is relief the deal does not require an immediate switch to EU pesticide rules. It had been feared this could result in a blow to farming incomes of up to £810million in the first year. The Government spokesperson said Britain has “secured transitional protections so farmers can continue to use a broad range of pesticides, alongside gaining access to EU-approved products”. However, industry body CropLife UK warned there is not yet a “workable plan for growers”.
Tom Bradshaw, president of the National Farmers’ Union, said the success of the deal will depend “on how it is implemented and the UK government’s ability to influence future EU rules that work for British farmers.” He warned of the lack of a level playing field, claiming the UK provides the “lowest level of agricultural support in Europe”.