Academic research has challenged the myth of monolithic union power during the 1970s 'winter of discontent', according to letters published in a recent newspaper. Dr Bryn Jones of the University of Bath argues that industrial actions were largely initiated by local and rank-and-file unionists frustrated with pay restraint policies that reduced real wages by 13% between 1975 and 1978. The TUC and other union 'barons' actually tried to restrain grassroots actions, contrary to popular depictions.
The impact of strikes was patchy and temporary. The tanker and delivery drivers' strike lasted just three weeks and affected only around 20% of the haulage industry, with negligible national impacts on foodstuffs. Local authority gravediggers' strikes were unofficial actions occurring only in Liverpool and Tameside for two weeks. Former Fleet Street editor Derek Jameson later recalled that press coverage made the crisis 'look like it was general, universal and eternal, when it was in reality scattered, here and there, and no great problem'.
Michael Somerton of Hull contrasts union power with corporate power, noting that highly paid executives make decisions behind closed doors with potentially permanent repercussions for workers and consumers. He argues that unions never wielded excessive power compared to employers, and that pundits and politicians lazily invoke the myth of overweening union power as an unassailable truth.