Constance denies SNP cover-up over NHS Grampian scandal
Constance denies SNP cover-up over NHS Grampian scandal

Angela Constance has denied that the SNP Government covered up the scandal at NHS Grampian, where patients suffered avoidable deaths at a hospital branded a "slaughterhouse". The Health Secretary said ministers had not deliberately avoided telling the public the scale of the issues, despite her predecessor Humza Yousaf being informed in 2022.

Report into avoidable deaths made public

Dr Mohammed Habib last week made public a bombshell report commissioned by the health board in 2022, which showed 19 avoidable deaths in liver and pancreatic surgery that had not been made public at the time. Dr Habib called for a corporate homicide probe into the health board, telling journalists he had tried to raise the issue with the police and Lord Advocate, as well as contacting the Scottish Government on four separate occasions.

Constance announced on Saturday an independent review into the handling of concerns at the health board, including those raised by the surgeon. The Health Secretary said she was looking for "100% transparency and accountability", adding: "I want absolute clarity about who knew what, when and what action was taken."

Government response under scrutiny

Constance stopped short of saying there had been a cover-up at the board, which earlier this month was the subject of a damning report from Health Improvement Scotland (HIS). Asked if the NHS was "broken", she said: "It's not. The vast, vast majority of patients receive excellent care and we have excellent frontline staff. In terms of issues around NHS Grampian, the HIS report couldn't have been clearer – this is not on frontline staff, this is on leadership and that's what we're addressing."

The Health Secretary will address Holyrood on Tuesday, naming the person who will head the review – who is expected to not be involved in the Scottish NHS – as well as its terms of reference. It comes after fresh details emerged that Yousaf, who was serving as health secretary at the time, and chief medical officer Professor Sir Gregor Smith attended a meeting in October 2022 where the report into the avoidable deaths was discussed.

Emails and political reaction

An email has also surfaced from a civil servant to former NHS Grampian medical director Professor Nick Fluck, where he was told of Dr Habib's attempts to reach ministers, but the Government response would be "very high level" and "basically just saying we are aware of the issue". Constance said the response from the Government "concerned me gravely, deeply", but added that her focus was "getting the job done, getting this review up and running quickly".

"It is clear that the Scottish Government knew of the 2022 report," she said. "What I now want to be assured of is how robustly we were looking at the details in that report and what was the response at the time. That's why we need that independent review, totally independent of Government, totally independent of NHS Scotland."

Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said it is clear there has been a cover-up. "There was in 2022 and we know that the health minister at the time, Humza Yousaf, knew about it, the chief medical officer knew about it," she said on the same programme. "I want to know what they did. Did they suspend surgery? Have they told the 19 (families) what actually happened in the case of their loved ones? Have they actually sacked any of the surgeons responsible? We don't know any of that because for four years now they've sat on this and not told anybody about it, and that goes to the very highest level of Government."

Baillie went on to say it should be for Holyrood to determine the parameters of the independent review as well as who leads it, claiming someone from outside Scotland should be brought in "to do a very quick and urgent review into what happened, who's responsible and how do we restore confidence and ensure patient safety is actually paramount".