South Shields MP Emma Lewell has warned that the North East mayor's plan to impose a new tourist tax would be "devastating" for her town. Speaking against Kim McGuinness' proposed levy on visitors, Ms Lewell said the charge would hit local accommodation providers and the wider hospitality industry.
Concerns over new levy powers
Under new legislation being put forward by the Government, Ms McGuinness would have the ability to introduce a charge on overnight stays at accommodation such as hotels, holiday lets, bed and breakfasts, and guesthouses. The Labour mayor has already faced a backlash from council leaders who sit in her cabinet, with local Reform UK and Tory figures opposed to the scheme, but she would have the power to impose the levy without their support.
During a House of Commons debate on Monday evening, Ms Lewell revealed major concerns about the proposals within Labour too. She said that "not a single bed and breakfast, caravan park or hotel owner" she had spoken to in South Shields was in support of the tax and cautioned against handing mayors the power to bring it in "regardless of the views of local people".
Impact on families and businesses
Ms Lewell warned that smaller destinations like South Shields are "not comparable" to European holiday hotspots like Barcelona and Venice, where similar visitor taxes are in force. She added: "This is not devolution; it is the centralisation of decision making in the hands of regional mayors. The hospitality industry, despite already carrying the highest tax burden in the UK, will be responsible for collecting and administering this tax, and the Bill outlines the criminal sanctions that businesses can expect to face if they do not do it properly."
She said the introduction of the tax, "even at £2 a person per night, would increase the cost of a week-long stay for a family of four by £56. That is a lot of money." Ms Lewell noted that the Government have acknowledged that the tax could push up the price of a holiday for Britons and force them abroad, adding that the knock-on effect "for my local accommodation providers but for the wider hospitality industry in South Shields, will be devastating".
Mayor's pledge and opposition
Implementing a visitor levy was part of Ms McGuinness' election manifesto and she has pledged to reinvest its proceeds back into improving the region's cultural attractions. While she had advocated for a £2-per-night charge, the Government said it instead wanted to "protect lower cost family breaks" by requiring it to be charged as a percentage of the cost of a stay rather than a flat rate. Ten mayors, including Ms McGuinness, have committed that they would not impose a charge above 5%.
Coun Guy Renner-Thompson, Chairman of Northumberland Conservatives, called on the mayor to "listen to the businesses and communities that would have to live with the consequences, including those in her own party who are now raising serious concerns". He added: "Northumberland's tourism businesses would be expected to collect the money, shoulder the bureaucracy and face the consequences, without any guarantee that the revenue would be spent in the communities where it was raised."
During Monday's debate, communities secretary Angela Rayner said the overnight levy would give mayors the ability to provide "more investment in local priorities, more new transport infrastructure and more regeneration". She told the Commons that, because visitor levies would be set as a percentage of the cost of accommodation, "low-cost holidays will stay low".
Ms McGuinness said previously: "The North East has vibrant cities, stunning coast and countryside in Northumberland and Durham and a welcome that keeps people coming back. A levy here will mean we can compete with rival destinations which already raise money from visitors." She added: "We want to double the scale of our tourist economy and create thousands of new jobs as we do so."