Angela Rayner's proposed employment reforms may "cripple" the pubs by placing significant financial pressure on the industry, experts have warned.
Under the proposed guaranteed-hours reforms, businesses will be required to closely track the working patterns of employees, including bar staff currently employed on zero-hours contracts. Workers would then be entitled to contracts reflecting the average number of hours they have worked during a specified reference period, which is expected to be around 12 weeks.
Compensation protections and industry concerns
The plans also include compensation protections, meaning employers could be required to pay staff if previously scheduled shifts are cancelled at short notice.
Such measures are designed to provide greater income security for workers, but hospitality firms have warned they could reduce flexibility and increase staffing costs.
Greene King chief warns of strike impact
Nick Mackenzie, chief executive of Greene King, which runs around 2,600 pubs, restaurants and hotels throughout England, Scotland and Wales, said the introduction of guaranteed-hours contracts risks leaving hospitality businesses unable to respond to sudden changes in customer demand.
Writing for The Telegraph, he said that the problem would be made worse by disruption such as the recent announcement of Tube strikes, which he said had caused "widespread dismay" across the sector and was an example of the sort of upset that could "cripple the industry" under the new regime.
Mr Mackenzie said: "Since 2022, UK Hospitality estimates that rail and Tube strikes have cost the sector more than £4bn. It is always challenging to manage a pub in these situations.
"The one saving grace is that managers can quickly adapt their team shift rotas to reflect these sudden changes in customer footfall.
"Our concern is, in the future, the Government's reforms to zero-hours contracts will make strikes even more difficult to navigate because managers will lose this flexibility and thereby face substantial costs."
Christmas hiring risks
He said: "Under the Government's current plans, hiring people in the busy Christmas period risks creating costs pubs cannot afford as they will have to offer similar hours across the following months, when demand will likely be lower.
"Pubs not being staffed sufficiently will result in customers facing long waits, businesses losing vital revenue, and employees missing the opportunity to work additional hours over one of the busiest weekends of the year."