Northern leaders react to Milburn's NEETs review and youth joblessness crisis
Northern leaders react to Milburn NEETs review and youth job crisis

Northern leaders have responded to Alan Milburn's long-awaited review into young people not in education, employment or training (NEET), which he described as a "moral crisis" for the nation. The review proposes shifting Britain from a "welfare state" to a "working state" to cut the youth NEET rate from 13% to 5% by 2036.

Jayne Worthington, CEO of The Progress Group, which runs alternative provision education providers mostly in the North of England, said she "completely agrees" with Milburn's assessment. However, she expressed disappointment that many of the proposals have been tried before under different names and then had their funding stopped.

Proposals and Reactions

The review's main recommendations include a Youth Opportunity Service providing every NEET young person with a dedicated adviser, and instant, needs-based youth mental health support without requiring a diagnosis. It also calls for overhauling under-25s' benefits, replacing Personal Independence Payment and Universal Credit health elements with a standard youth allowance, and investing billions upfront in job placements and training.

Worthington, who grew up on a deprived council estate in Birmingham, cited examples of past initiatives including intermediate labour markets, Sure Start, Future Jobs, Kickstart, and careers advice that were "rolled out and rolled back." She said, "I can name things like intermediate labour markets, Sure Start, Future Jobs, Kickstart, careers advice and guidance that got rolled out and rolled back. So I think many of these things have been tried and tried successfully, but the continuation of funding has ceased."

Regional Impact and Challenges

Of the ten areas with the highest rates of NEETs, eight are in the North of England: Stockton-on-Tees, Blackpool, South Tyneside, North East Lincolnshire, Halton, Hartlepool, Newcastle and Hull. Worthington described "heartbreaking" issues her teams deal with, including a child who took 45 minutes to eat one strawberry because he had been starved at home and in foster care.

She also criticised the focus on academic achievement in schools, saying, "What gets measured gets done, that's the saying. And Ofsted has gradually been turned into this 'you count the academics, you count the GCSEs, you count the A*s, you count the number of kids that go on to university'."

Despite the challenges, Worthington said she feels "quite optimistic" about the prospects of success, citing the pace of action and the track record of collaboration in Greater Manchester under Andy Burnham.

Voices from the Ground

In Manchester, 30-year-old Roman Dibden, founder of Breakout, a youth employment charity, shared his own experience of becoming NEET after his mother died around the time of his GCSEs. He spent eight months doing nothing before a careers adviser emailed him about an apprenticeship. He said, "The common thread over the years, what peed me off, is that we're still not asking why."

Dibden worried that "a lot of the resource is going to go to big providers putting on grassroots badges that are driven by money rather than having those relationships with the young people." He stressed the need for young people with lived experience to be involved in shaping provision.

North East Mayor Kim McGuinness said, "The North East has by some margin the highest rates of so-called NEETs in the country and the figures are stark: Nearly one in four of our young people are being denied the opportunities they deserve."

Kiran Fothergill, Chairman of The Jobs Foundation's North East Business Council and a director at Pickerings Lifts, told the BBC's Today show the recommendations sounded like "robbing Peter to pay Paul." He said employers' costs for hiring young people have gone up by about £4,000 in the last two years, and subsidies would not address the problem long term.

Teenagers Demi, Issa and Georgia, supported by Career Connect in Manchester's Moss Side, described months of unsuccessful job-hunting. Demi, 16, said, "I applied for loads of different colleges, and I've also been applying for retail jobs, and they just don't accept me because they said that you need like strict qualifications." Georgia added, "Companies aren't necessarily accommodating jobs to appeal to young people, rather than it being something that young people have to constantly seek out companies and large kind of employers."