Growing Up in North East Worse Now Than in 1980s, Milburn Warns
North East Youth Prospects Worse Than 1980s, Milburn Warns

Growing up in the North East is now worse than it was in the 1980s, according to the author of a landmark Government report on youth employment. Former Cabinet Minister Alan Milburn, who grew up in Newcastle's west end before becoming Darlington MP and Health Secretary, made the warning as he delivered his report on the large number of young people not in employment, education or training (NEET).

Report Calls for Major Reforms

Milburn has urged the Government to commit to a large programme of reforms to stop the NEET crisis from worsening. His recommendations include changes to benefits, support for young people, and incentives for employers to take on and train younger workers.

The report calls for the Government to spend around £5.8bn a year by 2036-37, funding a new youth opportunity service and support, including tax breaks and bonuses for firms employing young people. The cost would be offset by £3.6bn of annual welfare savings and £2.4bn of extra tax revenue from people in work.

A 'Moral Crisis'

Milburn said the increasing number of 16- to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training was a "moral crisis." Recalling his youth in the region, he said: "I've been incredibly lucky in my life. I grew up on a council estate and I had the fortune to end up serving in the Cabinet. I'm part of a generation that has, by and large, done pretty well."

He added: "We entered a labour market where the first rung of the career ladder was easier to reach. For many of us, housing was more affordable. We benefited from expanded educational opportunities - like so many people from our generation, I was the first in my family to go to university. And we inherited a simple promise from our parents: work hard and you build a better life."

"That great British promise for this generation is being broken. Our job is to fix it," he said. "The response to our interim report published in May has convinced me that there is a visceral mood for change in this country. Parents and grandparents feel it. Employers feel it and politicians feel it too. They all know that the risk of a lost generation of young people is real."

Structural Change

Milburn contrasted the current situation with the past, saying: "When I was growing up in politics, when I was active in the trade union movement in the North East of England, we were living through three million people being unemployed. It was terrible, de-industrialisation is what was happening."

"But the truth is that it was cyclical. The economy recovered and youth employment picked up. This is no longer cyclical, it's structural. It's young people not being in the labour market, they're detached from the labour market. They've never had the chance to be unemployed because they've never been employed."

Government Response

After the report's release, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said a new youth opportunities unit would be created by the Government and report directly to the Prime Minister. He also said out-of-work young people on benefits would be matched with a funded job after 12 months, rather than the current 18-month wait.

The Government's full response to Milburn's recommendations is expected next year, with North East mayor Kim McGuinness among those urging Ministers to take up its recommendations. Reacting to the report, the North East Chamber of Commerce's assistant director of policy Rachel Anderson said: "While the review sets out a 10-year programme of reform, young people in the North East cannot afford to wait a decade for meaningful change. Investment in employment, education and health support must come before changes to benefits, not follow them."

Beth Farhat, chair of the North East Child Poverty Commission, said: "With the country's highest rates of young people not earning or learning, nowhere is action to improve the support and opportunities available to our young people more pressing than here in the North East. As Alan Milburn has made clear, this is not about a shortage of ambition or aspirations – but barriers to accessing opportunity, which all too often include where a young person lives, their family background, a lack of networks or people willing to give them a first chance."

"Significantly investing in young people and the package of support around them – combined with a relentless focus on growing the number of good employment opportunities available in areas like ours – will be fundamental to turning this situation around," she added. "Importantly, the Milburn Review's reports have also emphasised that much of this crisis is rooted in poverty and inequality, and shaped by the conditions in which children grow up. The Government must therefore redouble its efforts to bring down the number of babies, children and young people growing up in poverty, to reduce their risk of becoming 'NEET' in the first place."