Alan Milburn's long-awaited report into Britain's 'Neets' crisis proposes a controversial shake-up of the welfare state, including an entirely new benefits system for under-25s, and warns the changes will not be 'pain-free'.
The former Labour Health Secretary's review, presented to Andy Burnham's Cabinet on Tuesday morning, calls for a new benefits system for under-25s, with some young people set to lose financial support.
The review states: "These changes will not be easy to make. Nor will they be pain-free. They could mean some people get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system."
"But the approach I have taken is to try to define what would give young people the best chance of building a good life, not just over a year or two but over the course of their lifetimes."
Multi-billion pound boost for work support
The report also demands a multi-billion pound boost from the government in work support schemes to help almost half a million young people into work by 2036. It recommends an initial £500 million cash injection, rising to a £5.8 billion annual boost by 2036-2037.
Speaking on Tuesday morning, Mr Milburn said: "Some people - I don't deny this - some people will be worse off, initially. At the same time we're putting in more money in kind, in support, in services, in opportunities, to enable young people to do what they want to do, which is to get a job."
His interim report, published in the spring, warned that without action, the UK could see the number of young people classed as 'Neets' surging to over 1.2 million, with a £125 billion annual hit to the economy.
Neet Zero ambition and legal guarantee
A new "national ambition" to reach a Neet rate of 5% within a decade is central to the report. Currently, just shy of one million young people between the ages of 16 and 24 (13%) are not in employment, education, or training. Only Romania has a higher Neet rate in Europe than the UK.
The report states: "By 2036, the UK should aim to reduce the Neet rate to around 5% and become one of Europe's best-performing countries for youth participation."
"This will be an effective rate of Neet Zero. Full youth participation. Full employment and full education for the young. The end of long-term youth unemployment."
Achieving this reduction will require the "creation of opportunity on a new scale", with modelling suggesting an extra 500,000 work and education opportunities will be needed by 2036. This includes 25,000 "pre-apprenticeship" places and up to 270,000 under-25 apprenticeship starts each year by 2026.
The report details the need for a £500 million initial investment in 2027-2028 from existing Whitehall budgets, and a £5.8 billion annual injection by 2036-2037. It claims the figure would be offset by £3.6 billion in welfare savings and £2.4 billion of extra tax revenue from people in work.
Another key recommendation is a legal duty on the government to give all young people the offer of work, training, or education, with a "generational promise that every young person will be guaranteed the opportunity to earn or learn". This could include apprenticeship routes or a government-subsidised job with employers receiving £3,000 for each youngster they recruit.
The report presents this as a "new deal" between young people and the state, but makes clear there will be consequences for those who refuse to engage. It adds: "A young person who persistently refuses to engage, after attempts to understand why after reasonable routes to re-engagement have been tried, should ultimately lose their youth allowance benefit."
"Sanctions should be rare and reviewed regularly. But a deal without consequences is not a deal."
Benefits shake-up for under-25s
The most contentious section of the report is the proposed shake-up of benefits for under-25s. Mr Milburn argues that "the best reform option is one that has never been tried before - the creation of a new and different system for young people from the one that serves older adults".
This includes abolishing the health element of Universal Credit for young people and introducing a new "youth allowance". A new "additional cost allowance" will replace the current Personal Independence Payments (PIP) for young people. According to July's figures, over 450,000 16- to 24-year-olds in England and Wales were entitled to receive PIP.
There will be a new and more financially generous "severe and complex needs" insurance scheme for the minority of young people where it is clear they will likely never be able to work.
The report says the new system, if introduced by government, should apply to those already Neet and those who become so. It makes clear the changes will not be "pain-free", with some young people receiving less financial support than under the current system.
The Resolution Foundation's Ruth Curtice says: "The biggest winners may well be those already in work, while those with health conditions who struggle to work could lose out."
"The move away from a 'left alone' approach to welfare is welcome, though the overall benefit savings of £3.6 billion by 2036-37 that Milburn says his programme would achieve suggest that some young people – likely those whose health or disability prevents them from working – could be considerably worse off."
National Insurance cut and work allowance
The report rejects an "across-the-board" National Insurance cut for firms but proposes a £1.1 billion a year boost for business. This includes gradually cutting NI costs over five years for companies' workers between the ages of 21 and 24, starting in the retail and hospitality sectors, which are responsible for 37% of all jobs for those under 25.
Mr Milburn adds: "The best way of doing that is by doubling the point at which employer National Insurance becomes payable for those young people, from the current £5,000 threshold to £10,000."
Bosses should also be offered between £3,000 and £7,000 for hiring those who have been Neets for six months.
The Mirror first revealed the recommendation to give young people a new "work allowance" to stop their benefits being reduced from the first pound they earn. Under existing rules, only those with children or claimants assessed as having limited capability for work get such an allowance. Everyone else loses 55p of benefit for every £1 they earn, starting from the first £1 of earned income.
Under Mr Milburn's proposal, every young person currently in receipt of benefits would get a work allowance set at a value of 16 hours a week at the minimum wage. His report states: "Today a young person without children or who has not demonstrated incapacity for work has no work allowance at all."
"That needs to change where full-time work is not yet possible in order to better make part-time work pay. Many young people who are Neet are likely to be able to work ten or fifteen hours a week initially with a view of progressing to full-time work later."
Health reforms and care leavers
The report warns that poor mental or physical health "should not become a one-way route out of education and work". Young people should, as a starting point, be able to get help online "through trusted channels and via the NHS app", ensuring they get immediate advice and support rather than waiting for a diagnosis or assessment.
Those deemed to have lower-level needs should have these addressed as soon as possible "and at the least intensive effective level", with specialist clinical capacity "reserved for those who need it most".
Mr Milburn criticised a "cash for diagnosis" approach in some private providers carrying out ADHD and autism assessments, saying some young people are being failed when they get a diagnosis despite not meeting the appropriate threshold, "or when they should not get one".
He urged the Government to take swift action on the private sector by restricting or cutting their NHS funding if they fail to meet required standards, and bringing in a new payment mechanism by 2028 "based on quality and outcomes rather than assessment or diagnosis volumes".
Care leavers who are out of education, employment or training should be given a £50-per-week payment, the review proposes. Mr Milburn said he believes the state has a "particular obligation to young people who have been in its care".
He added: "I propose an Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA)-style care leaver transition allowance of £50 a week for care leavers who are Neet or at serious risk. Care leavers should not face a penalty for having been in the care of the state; they should receive some of the stability that other young people can rely on from their families. If successful, the allowance could be extended to other at-risk groups."