Alan Milburn has urged Andy Burnham to spend billions of pounds on a "new deal" for the next generation, funding guaranteed jobs support for young people to offset a radical cut in benefits. The proposal comes in a watershed report on Britain's youth jobs crisis, which warns the country is at a "fork in the road" after the number of young people not in education, employment or training (Neet) surged to almost a million.
Radical welfare overhaul proposed
Milburn, the Tony Blair-era health secretary, said ministers faced a choice: continue down a path of state and market failure, or adopt a 10-year plan with an ambition to eradicate long-term youth unemployment. The blueprint calls for a sweeping shake-up of welfare, education, health and employment policy to ensure every young person has the chance to earn or learn.
If adopted, the review claims Britain could halve the number of young people neither earning nor learning, helping about 600,000 more under-25s into education, employment or training each year by 2036. The UK's Neet rate has reached 13%, the highest level since 2014, driven by rising joblessness as employers freeze hiring amid the fallout from the war in the Middle East, alongside the legacies of the Covid pandemic and austerity, a rise in mental ill-health, and AI upending the jobs market. Milburn said that rate could be lowered to 5% by 2036.
New welfare system for under-25s
Central to the plan is a controversial shake-up of the benefits system, treating under-25s as wholly separate from the working-age population at large. Milburn urged the prime minister not to shy away from welfare reform, after Keir Starmer was forced into a climbdown over a plan to cut disability benefits amid pressure from Labour MPs. At a press conference in London on Tuesday, Milburn is expected to say: "It is time for a new settlement that makes work not welfare the future for the next generation."
But Milburn warned that crude benefit cuts would not work, arguing that changes would need upfront investment. The blueprint proposes an entirely new welfare system for young people with tougher eligibility criteria than for older claimants. In exchange, there would be a drastic step-change in support to help young people find work, including a new "youth opportunity service" in England, accountable to regional mayors and local leaders, combining employment, careers, health and practical support. Young people would receive a personalised participation plan and a named adviser, with access guaranteed by two new legal guarantees.
Concerns over poverty and political backlash
Some young people with health conditions and disabilities would lose access to current benefits, though they could apply to a local fund for short-term expenses and equipment. Those with the most profound health conditions, unable ever to work, would still get more generous financial support. Analysis in the report shows that for every £1 spent on helping young people into work or education, the state spent £25 on youth benefits last year; under the proposals, that would be rebalanced to £2 to £1.
The changes have raised fears among some Labour MPs and charities that slashing youth benefits could plunge more young people into poverty. Left-wing backbenchers, including Nadia Whittome, Bell Ribeiro-Addy, John McDonnell, Apsana Begum, Clive Lewis and Richard Burgon, warned in a letter that an entire generation risked becoming disconnected from work and wider society. "What young people need is not more punishment, but more opportunity," they wrote, warning that an approach relying on benefit cuts "risks further disenfranchising young people who are already struggling".
To ease concerns, Milburn held meetings with MPs on Monday alongside the work and pensions secretary, Pat McFadden, who told backbenchers: "What is proposed is a new settlement for young people. This is not last year's proposal with better PR. It's about bringing together the help young people need in one place – treating them as a person not a departmental client." Milburn said Britain had faced a Neet problem for 25 years and had never made a plan to end it before: "We are at a fork in the road and half measures will not do. A complete system reset is needed. A lost generation is not inevitable. A work generation is possible."
The shadow work and pensions secretary, Helen Whately, criticised the review as "too cautious on reversing that damage and too often his answer is the big and expensive hand of the state", adding that it "fails to bring down the welfare bill, proposes billions more in government spending and won't make the slightest difference for young people stuck on welfare now – because nothing will happen for at least three years".