A government-commissioned review has proposed doubling the threshold at which businesses start paying National Insurance (NI) for 21 to 24-year-olds, a move small business owners say would "massively" help them reduce staffing costs.
The report, led by former Labour minister Alan Milburn, suggests raising the threshold from £5,000 to £10,000. It follows figures showing nearly one million 16-24 year-olds are not in employment, education or training, a group known as Neets.
The proposal could particularly benefit retail and hospitality firms, which provide 40 per cent of jobs for young people in the UK.
Business Owners Welcome the Proposal
Cafe owners Jade and Dan Rossiter, who run Good Vibes coffee shop in Falmouth, Cornwall, said they no longer employ any full-time staff due to NI and VAT costs. The couple opened the shop 10 years ago with a chef and a barista, but now do the work themselves.
Jade, 38, told The Mirror: "Dan is now the chef six days a week and I'm the barista. We no longer have any full time staff. Paying less NI would allow us to pay the staff we do have more money and offer them more hours. The money would go back into the business. Any reduction in costs is a good thing."
Pub owners Hannah and Richard Chellingsworth, who took on the Yew Tree in Canterbury, Kent, two years ago, also said an NI reduction would help. Hannah, 48, said: "Any reduction in NI is going to help us. The cost is huge. It would allow us to take on more staff and as a result give us more bandwidth to run the business successfully. We would love to have a bigger team to effectively and efficiently serve our customers and better serve the demand - it would massively improve our turnover and payroll."
Impact on Apprentices and Other Proposals
Salon owner Claire Hildreth, who runs At Sisters Hair and Beauty in Newcastle, said she has had to cut the number of young apprentices she employs because of NI costs. She currently employs three apprentices aged 19, 20 and 21.
"National Insurance contributions affect us massively – we don't have as many as we used to, and many salons no longer employ apprentices because of it," she said. "We currently have three apprentices, a 21-year-old, a 20-year-old and a 19-year-old. If we were paying less NI we might be able to take on more, but that's not currently possible."
The report, which has been in the works for a year, also suggests under-25s should no longer be able to claim the health element of Universal Credit or personal independence payment (Pip). Milburn also urges the government to make getting a job, training or employment support a legal guarantee.
At present, businesses pay no employer NI contributions for workers younger than 21 or for apprentices under 25, unless they earn above £50,270. For non-apprentices aged 21-24, employers pay 15% on annual earnings above £5,000, a situation in place since April 2025 after then Chancellor Rachel Reeves increased the rate from 13.8% and lowered the threshold from £9,100.