Milburn Review Echoes Burnham's Manchesterism in Welfare Overhaul
Milburn Review Echoes Burnham's Manchesterism in Welfare Plan

Alan Milburn's review of youth unemployment, 'From a Welfare State to a Working State', calls for a radical restructuring of the welfare state, with more power handed to regional mayors and greater cooperation between public services. The review, commissioned to address a crisis that has left nearly one million young people outside education, employment or training, explicitly identifies Greater Manchester as a model the rest of the country should follow.

Milburn's Proposals Echo Burnham's Philosophy

The former Labour cabinet minister's review proposes overhauling the benefits system for under-25s, transforming how schools prepare children for working life, and creating hundreds of thousands of new employment and training opportunities. Reading between the lines of the report's 278 pages, there is also a profound argument about how Britain should be governed.

Milburn believes the country cannot tackle youth employment through a collection of short-lived initiatives devised by individual government departments. Instead, he suggests a radical redrawing of the relationship between central government, local leaders, employers and public services.

"The new system cannot work if responsibility is local but money and power remain in Whitehall," he writes. "Radical devolution of powers, responsibilities and resources is needed."

Greater Manchester as a Model

Milburn wants regional mayors and other strategic authorities to take responsibility for ensuring young people aged 16 to 24 are engaged in education, employment or training. They would oversee new Youth Opportunity Services, bringing together employment support, education, skills and other services that currently operate separately. Crucially, they would receive devolved funding and commissioning powers through new agreements with central government.

As the Manchester Evening News reported exclusively last night, mayor of Greater Manchester Bev Craig has already committed to creating a new deputy mayor who will act as the city-region's skills commissioner in response to the report.

Milburn also proposes that areas which successfully reduce youth economic inactivity should be allowed to share in the financial savings. The proposal is predicated on the idea that those who live, work and care about places are the best people to make decisions about them.

NHS Governance and Public Services

In a section examining how the NHS could better support young people into work, Milburn singles out Greater Manchester and South Yorkshire for developing arrangements that bring health services and mayoral government closer together. Both areas have combined the roles of Integrated Care Board chair and Mayoral Health Commissioner, creating a position accountable to NHS leadership and the elected mayor.

"By 2029 the governance mechanisms that are being pioneered in Greater Manchester and South Yorkshire should become the default in all parts of the country," he writes.

Milburn argues that Britain's public services are too often organised around institutions rather than people. Schools, the NHS, Jobcentres and local authorities each operate according to their own rules, budgets and priorities - meaning that for a young person struggling with poor mental health, unemployment or difficult family circumstances, navigating that system can be almost impossible and frequently infuriating. His proposed solution is to bring those services together around the individual, with local leaders responsible for making the system work.

Implications for Greater Manchester

Milburn's review began before Burnham became Prime Minister, and many of the ideas it contains have been knocking about in public policy circles for years. There is also a distinction between praising Greater Manchester's governance arrangements and demonstrating that they have delivered better outcomes - a question that deserves real scrutiny.

The implications could be considerable for Greater Manchester, where the mayor and combined authority could find themselves taking on far greater responsibility for the prospects of tens of thousands of young people. But with those powers would come greater accountability. If young people continue to struggle to find employment, or remain trapped outside education and training, it would become harder for local leaders to argue that responsibility lies entirely with Westminster. That may prove to be one of the most important tests of the philosophy Burnham has championed.