Alan Milburn has warned his blueprint to tackle Britain's 'Neets' crisis will not be "pain-free", with some young people set to lose financial support. The ex-Labour Cabinet minister's long-awaited report, spanning over 270 pages, proposes a controversial welfare state shake-up for under-25s, combined with a multi-billion pound boost in support schemes to help the almost one million young people aged 16 to 24 back into employment, education, or training.
£5.8bn plan to tackle youth unemployment
Mr Milburn, who addressed Andy Burnham's Cabinet on Tuesday with his findings, recommends an initial £500million cash injection in the 2027 spending review. By 2036-2037, he said this should rise to a £5.8billion annual boost to help over 440,000 youngsters back into work.
His 10-year plan to radically reduce the UK's 'Neet' rate includes a first-of-its-kind legal guarantee for young people to offer work or training and a duty on government to deliver. His proposal will be made possible by annual welfare savings of £3.6billion and £2.4billion in extra tax revenues from people in work.
New benefits system for under-25s
Among the most contentious and politically thorny proposals, Mr Milburn proposes an entirely new and different benefits system for under-25s. His report argues the "best reform option is one that has never been tried before - the creation of a new and different system for young people from the one that serves older adults".
It involves a new "youth allowance" replacing the health element of Universal Credit (UC) and the personal independence payment (PIP) for 16 to 24-year-olds. Under the new system, the report says those with conditions such as anxiety, ADHD and autism "would be both expected and enabled to work". But there will be a new and more financially generous "severe and complex needs" insurance scheme for the minority of young people where it is clear they will likely never be able to work, the report states.
His report, published on Tuesday, is frank, adding: "These changes will not be easy to make. Nor will they be pain-free. They could mean some people get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system."
Political reaction and concerns
Launching his report at a press conference at Google's offices in central London, Mr Milburn said: "Britain is at risk of losing a generation of young people, not because they lack talent, not because they lack ambition, not because they do not want to work. This is not a crisis of aspiration, it is a crisis of opportunity."
Mr Burnham described the publication of the report as a "watershed moment". He said: "I said to the cabinet this morning, I don't think a British Cabinet has sat around that table in 50 years or more and talked about a vision for young people, support from the very early years all the way through school and then into opportunity beyond school."
Pressed on whether he was going to cut benefits for young people, the Prime Minister told Sky News: "I don't want anybody to lose out here. This is not about punishing anybody. It's about saving money because young people are moving from education, training and into work and there's no need for anybody to miss out."
Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden told MPs that Mr Burnham's Cabinet has endorsed the need for a whole new settlement for young people. MPs will get a vote on government plans next year, with a white paper due to be published once ministers have considered the whole report. It will be combined with a response to the upcoming Timms review on the main disability benefit, Personal Independence Payments (PIP).
Some left-wing MPs have already expressed concern, including Jeremy Corbyn's former Shadow Chancellor, John McDonnell. He said: "The receipt of Pip and universal credit health elements keeps 120,000 young people out of poverty. So the question does remain: why is it that young people, if benefit cuts go ahead, are forced to pay for the new system and we're not taxing wealth?"
The Resolution Foundation's Ruth Curtice said the report rose to the challenge the country faces in providing enough education, employment, and training opportunities for young people. But she added: "The proposed welfare reforms are likely to be the most contested aspect of this review even though they'll play a relatively small role in tackling Britain's NEET crisis."
James Taylor, executive director of strategy at the disability equality charity Scope, welcomed the "ambition to transform employment support for young people" but said they are "deeply concerned by proposals that could leave some young disabled people with less financial support". George Bangham from the New Economics Foundation said: "There's much to welcome in Alan Milburn's review, including calls for more investment in employment support and a guarantee of a job, training or support for every young person. But the positives risk being overshadowed by his argument for cuts to health and disability benefits."