Milburn's £5.8bn youth plan: benefits overhaul sparks worry
Milburn £5.8bn youth plan: benefits overhaul sparks worry

A landmark government-commissioned report, led by former Health Secretary Alan Milburn, sets out a £5.8 billion rescue plan to guarantee young people a route into work, an apprenticeship or training. The proposals, which would cost up to £5.8 billion annually, include a major overhaul of the welfare system for under-25s, raising concerns about the impact on the most vulnerable young adults.

Welfare overhaul for under-25s

The report proposes separating under-25s from the adult welfare system. For 18-to-24-year-olds, the Universal Credit health top-up would be scrapped in favour of a single 'Youth Allowance', alongside strict rules meaning those who refuse to engage with job offers face sanctions if they persistently refuse to engage or turn down reasonable offers without good cause, after attempts to re-engage them.

Personal Independence Payment (PIP), currently worth up to £778.40 every four weeks, would be scrapped for under-25s. It would be replaced by a targeted 'Additional Cost Allowance' for those with significant, ongoing disability costs, a more generous 'Severe and Complex Needs Insurance' for those with the most profound disabilities who will never be able to work, and a local flexible disability fund for others. It is thought some of the 453,000 who currently claim it would no longer be eligible, with a tightening on eligibility.

Child Disability Living Allowance (DLA) would be extended from age 16 to 18. Around 77 per cent of Child DLA claimants transition directly onto PIP by age 17, prompting this proposed overhaul.

Education and early intervention

The review makes it clear that prevention has to start early, with primary and secondary schools identifying pupils at risk of becoming Neet. Key proposals include raising the national ambition so that by 2036, at least 90% of children are school-ready at age five, which includes basic independence like being out of nappies.

Drawing on the legacy of Sure Start, it calls for expanding Family Hubs into a national programme, especially in disadvantaged areas. There would be a new writing, numeracy and oracy check around Year 8, which wouldn't be an exam but a check on how students are performing. Schools would have more timetable flexibility to tailor learning to pupil strengths, and would be required to offer work experience.

The report also aims to double the number of young people completing apprenticeships, introduce new vocational GCSEs from age 14, lighten the examination burden which sees pupils sit all their exams in an intense six-week period, and implement phone-free school days and social media curbs for under-16s.

Autism, ADHD and mental health

With sky-high waiting lists for youth mental health assessments, Milburn has warned that poor health "should not become a one-way route out of education and work". Rather than getting stuck in a bottleneck as they await a formal diagnosis, the report says NEETs should have guaranteed access to fast-track services like talking therapies and counselling within three months, even without a diagnosis.

Milburn has criticised a "cash for diagnosis" approach from some private providers who carry out ADHD and autism assessments, and said some young people are being failed when they get a diagnosis "when they should not get one".

The Prime Minister has said the report should be a "watershed moment", but the Government did not immediately commit to implementing all the changes demanded by Mr Milburn.