DWP urged to overhaul Universal Credit and PIP for under-25s
DWP urged to overhaul benefits for under-25s

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has been urged to make major changes to Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payments (PIP) for all claimants under the age of 25. A report into youth unemployment, published on Tuesday morning, recommends significant cuts to these benefits as part of plans to reduce the number of 16 to 24-year-olds not in education, employment, or training, a group known as 'Neets'.

The number of Neets topped one million earlier this year for the first time in more than a decade. The report's author, Alan Milburn, has called on the government to back the sweeping reforms, which would cut benefit payments for some young people.

New Youth Allowance Proposed

Under Mr Milburn's plan, people under 25 would no longer be eligible for PIP or the health element of Universal Credit. Instead, a new Youth Allowance would be introduced for claimants under 25. Mr Milburn said the changes would not be "surgical tweaks" but would create "an entirely new benefit system for young people".

The report stated that the new single Youth Allowance would be set at the standard rate of Universal Credit for claimants under 25, with a higher rate for those living independently. The changes would see the health top-up and the work capability assessment for Universal Credit abolished. The Youth Allowance would also provide guaranteed support and opportunities to participate in learning or earning, the report said.

Replacing PIP and Additional Support

To replace PIP for young people, a new Additional Cost Allowance would be introduced. This would provide "targeted financial support where disability-related extra costs are well established, significant, and ongoing", the report stated. Awards would be made through a national, healthcare-professional-led assessment.

The plans would also introduce a new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance, described in the report as "a more generous and long-term award without a qualifying period, for the small minority of young people with the most profound and long-term disabilities, where it is already clear they will likely never be able to work".

Mr Milburn said the new welfare system should apply to current Neets claiming benefits and those who become so. "Young people entering the welfare system for the first time should move onto the new benefits system, with phased rollout starting within the lifetime of this Parliament, subject to legislation," he said.

Impact on Claimants and Reactions

The changes will affect PIP claimants with anxiety, depression, ADHD, and autism, who currently form the majority of new claimants. "In the current system, young people with these conditions often end up trapped on benefits, when under the new system they would be both expected and enabled to be in work," Mr Milburn said.

The report acknowledged that the plans will leave some people with "less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system". However, it argued that the changes would "give young people the best chance of building a good life, not just over a year or two but over the course of their lifetimes".

Mr Milburn said the reforms were expected to help around 440,000 young people into sustained work by 2036. He added that while benefits for over 25s were not part of the review's remit, the government could consider applying the changes to older cohorts as well. He admitted his proposed changes will not be easy or "pain-free", but said they will result in a welfare system that can "gift young people a future" rather than just writing them off with a cheque.

Charities have voiced concern at the idea of cutting benefit support, which is currently aimed at covering the extra costs of living with a disability. Harriet Edwards from disability charity Sense said: "We share Alan Milburn's ambition to break down the barriers that prevent young disabled people who want to work from doing so." She added: "We urge the government to provide urgent reassurance that no young disabled person with complex needs will be left worse off."