Citizens Advice Scotland has warned that proposed changes to disability benefits could leave young people struggling financially and push them further away from work and training. The charity said reducing incomes could lead to financial hardship and make it harder for young disabled people to move into employment or education.
Milburn review recommends overhaul
The warning follows the publication of a long-awaited review by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn into the rising number of young people not in education, employment or training. The report recommends a major overhaul of support for under-25s, including replacing Personal Independence Payment (PIP) with a new system designed to help young people with disabilities and health conditions move towards work where possible.
However, Mr Milburn acknowledges that some young people could receive less financial support under the proposed arrangements, at least at the beginning of a claim.
Emma Jackson, assistant director at Citizens Advice Scotland, said: “It would be a completely backwards step to push young disabled people into financial hardship by reducing incomes.
“This is totally contrary to what people need to be able to move forward positively. Advisers at local CABs know insufficient incomes make people unwell – pushing people into poverty and even further away from work or training.”
Call for more detail in Scotland
Ms Jackson said the charity welcomed the prospect of a joined-up, long-term plan, with young people receiving tailored support over a 12-month period. But she added that more detail was needed about how the proposals could work in Scotland and what was being planned for social security.
Ms Jackson said: “We need to see how initiatives like this could work in practice here in Scotland and better understand the proposals for social security.”
She also called for the experiences of disabled people with complex needs to be recognised, with meaningful support available regardless of whether they are able to work.
Three new forms of support proposed
Under Mr Milburn’s proposals, PIP for under-25s would be replaced by three different forms of support. An Additional Cost Allowance would help those with significant, established and ongoing disability-related costs. A local Health and Disability Fund would provide help for immediate or changing needs, while a Severe and Complex Needs Insurance payment would support young people with the most profound and enduring disabilities who would not realistically be able to work.
The report also recommends replacing the existing approach to health-related support through Universal Credit for under-25s, with a new Youth Allowance and a greater focus on helping young people participate in education, training or employment.
Mr Milburn said the intention is to provide more practical help and support, rather than simply paying benefits. However, he accepts some young people could receive less financial support at the start of a claim. The report states existing claimants would move to the new arrangements when the system was established in their area and their scheduled reassessment was due.
Implications for Scotland
The proposals have important implications for Scotland, where disability benefits are devolved. PIP is not paid in Scotland, where Adult Disability Payment is administered by Social Security Scotland. Any changes to the Scottish disability benefit would therefore be a matter for the Scottish Government.
Universal Credit, including its health-related element, is a UK-wide benefit. The report sets out a UK-wide diagnosis of the problems facing young people, but said devolved governments will be responsible for considering how its principles should apply in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
Citizens Advice Scotland said it was awaiting further details before assessing what the proposals could mean for young people north of the Border.