Burnham Government Plan to Boost 'Trustworthy' News on Social Media Faces Backlash
Burnham's 'Trustworthy' News Plan Draws Criticism

Ministers are considering legislative options to label certain news outlets as "trustworthy" and require platforms such as Instagram and YouTube to adjust their algorithms to promote this content in users' feeds. The government has not confirmed who would decide which outlets receive the designation.

Two justifications have been offered for the intervention: providing financial support to Public Service Media (PSM) providers like the BBC and ITV amid declining traditional TV viewership, and protecting the public from mis- and disinformation.

Concerns Over Government Interference

Big Brother Watch, a civil liberties group, argues the approach is problematic in practice and in principle. The group suggests that being labelled "trustworthy" by the government could damage PSMs by making them appear aligned with the government's agenda.

For outlets not granted the designation, platforms would likely reduce their visibility in feeds. The News Media Association, in its consultation response, warns that "the path of least resistance for platforms is to promote public service broadcaster content, transferring visibility and revenue from the commercial press."

Parliamentary Opposition

Sir John Whittingdale MP, a member of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee and former Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport, expressed concerns about disinformation but called the prominence proposals "a very dangerous extension of Government interference in the freedom of the press and the right to free speech."

Big Brother Watch contends that algorithmic changes would not solve mis- and disinformation, noting that academic research indicates such content is mainly consumed by a small minority who actively seek it out. The group argues these individuals would not change their views if more Channel 4 content appeared in their feeds.

User Empowerment vs. Government Control

The consultation acknowledges that "evidence shows that in times of major news events or local incidents, citizens turn to more traditional forms of news outlets such as the local newspaper, local radio stations or PSM news."

Big Brother Watch states it is not advocating for Big Tech control either, noting that YouTube and Meta should not decide for users. The group points to the green paper's principle of "user empowerment" and argues ministers should hand control to users rather than take it themselves. The group concludes that if someone wants a feed full of PSM content, or none at all, that is their business, not the government's.