Labour's Youth Job Guarantee scheme, due to be announced on Tuesday, is a sham, according to Express columnist Esther McVey. The plan puts a legal requirement on the state to provide a subsidised job at a cost of billions, yet it won't replace the jobs that were needlessly taxed away and previously available at no cost to the taxpayer.
McVey argues that Rachel Reeves' National Insurance raid, alongside huge minimum wage hikes, hammered youth employment, leaving nearly one million young people out of work, education, or training. Instead of admitting the mistake and reversing their tax on jobs, Andy Burnham and his ministers have cooked up another expensive Whitehall gimmick.
Scheme Architect Admits High Cost and Limited Jobs
Former Blair minister Alan Milburn, the architect of the scheme, openly confesses it'll cost billions, will take a decade before it saves the Treasury a single penny, and will provide only 90,000 guaranteed jobs by March 2029. McVey calls this a gigantic jobs con and a pricey piece of political theatre designed to get Labour off the hook for engineering a youth unemployment crisis.
Since Labour came to power, roughly 644,000 UK businesses have ceased trading. Jobs are few and far between, and the businesses that traditionally gave teenagers their first break, like pubs and shops, are rapidly vanishing from high streets. With the new "tourist tax" levy on hospitality marching through Parliament this week, most businesses still clinging on aren't looking to recruit extra staff.
Proposals Threaten Saturday Jobs and Small Businesses
Absurd new Government proposals to be consulted on this month seek to force bosses to get permission from their local council or receive a £1,000 fine. McVey questions why hard-pressed small businesses would hire untested 21- or 22-year-olds, each costing roughly £28,000 to £32,000 a year in wages, Employer National Insurance Contributions, pension, and overheads, just to pocket a £3,000 to £7,000 Government handout, especially when Angela Rayner's Employment Rights Act hands every new starter day-one workers' rights.
In truth, these taxpayer-funded placements will inevitably end up in the only place Labour knows how to expand – the already bloated public sector. The vicious circle grinds on, with an ever-growing state sector squeezing the life out of an overtaxed and over regulated private sector. Even Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden squirmed when asked if the working-age benefits bill will fall before the next election, refusing to promise it would.
Call for Tax Cuts and Deregulation
McVey concludes that no amount of Whitehall posturing and job subsidies will work while the Government continues to strangle the private sector. If Labour wants to get Britain's youth working, they just need to cut taxes on businesses and stop unnecessary regulations. She argues that you can't tax and regulate your way to economic growth, and it is young, unemployed people who will continue to pay the price.