Age of consent change wouldn't stop teen abuse, says parents editor
Age of consent change wouldn't stop teen abuse, says editor

Calls for a staggered age of consent following the Russell Brand court case would not stop teenagers from being abused, according to parents editor Emma Gill.

Writing in a new opinion piece, Gill argues that a person turning 16 is no different from the 15-year-old who went to bed the night before, and that there is no magic transformation which suddenly makes them capable of handling contraception and relationships.

Pressure on the government

The court case involving Russell Brand has sparked calls for a change to the law, with allegations against author and TV presenter David Walliams also fuelling debate. Prime Minister Andy Burnham has said he will not “rush in” with plans to change the age of consent amid rising pressure on the government.

The pressure has mounted after a woman who waived her anonymity to publicly allege Brand raped her as a 16-year-old schoolgirl called for changes to the law. Brand, 51, is serving a 10-and-a-half-year prison term after he was convicted of one count of rape and three sexual assaults at Southwark Crown Court on November 5. Allegations from the woman, who alleges Brand raped her when she was 16, were not part of his trial.

What the law change would mean

Gill notes that it doesn't seem right that a 40-year-old could legally have sex with a 16-year-old, but as the law currently stands, that's the case. It's only if the older person is in a position of trust, such as a teacher or a sports coach, that they are prevented from having sex with a 16 or 17-year-old.

She says the Close the Consent Gap campaign wants the change to apply to relationships with a gap of just four years or more, meaning it would be a criminal offence for a 17-year-old to have sex with their 22-year-old partner. Gill questions whether that is the road to go down, and says she can't see that realistically being policed.

The bigger issue

Gill argues that putting an age on it doesn't really define when a person is mature enough to have sex, and that the risk of coercion and grooming is just as high once a person turns 18. She says a teenager's 'yes' should never be regarded as equal to that of a person sometimes decades older.

The sad reality, she says, is that it's often the most vulnerable in society who are preyed on for sexual exploitation, and there are already laws and systems in place to help protect them. The fact that those systems seem to fail so many and result in laws not being enforced is the bigger issue, and changing the age of consent isn't going to alter that.