Hackney's mayor has accused the Home Office of attempting to pressure council officials into cancelling a political event featuring a Palestine Action co-founder and a controversial academic.
Zoë Garbett has written to the Home Secretary demanding answers over what she described as an "assault on the right to free speech" after government officials contacted the council ahead of a discussion held in the borough earlier this month.
Event and Government Contact
The event, organised by left-wing magazine Tribune at the Rose Lipman Building in De Beauvoir on November 4, featured Palestine Action co-founder Huda Ammori and was due to include Swedish climate scholar Andreas Malm by video link. Mr Malm had previously been refused entry to the UK after being informed by immigration authorities that his presence in the country might not be considered conducive to the public good.
Documents disclosed under Freedom of Information laws show Home Office officials contacted Hackney Council ahead of the event and suggested officers consider anti-terror legislation when assessing arrangements. One email referenced concerns that a speaker was publicly advertised as the co-founder of a proscribed organisation. Palestine Action was banned by the Government in 2025, with the decision currently being challenged through the courts.
Mayor's Letter and Home Office Response
Ms Garbett claims the Home Office's intervention created pressure on council officers to explore cancelling the event. In a letter published on Monday, she said: "Encouraging the cancellation of lawful public events represents an assault on the right to free speech."
However, the Home Office rejected the allegation and insisted it had not sought to prevent the meeting from taking place. A spokesperson said: "It is categorically untrue to suggest the Home Office pushed for this event to be cancelled." The department said it routinely provides local authorities with relevant information so they can make their own decisions where there may be concerns relating to extremism, radicalisation or support for proscribed organisations.
Council Officers' Pushback
Emails disclosed under FOI laws appear to show council officers pushing back against suggestions they wanted the event cancelled. In one exchange, an unnamed officer wrote: "Hackney Council has no mandate to cancel this event and I can categorically state that at no point have I suggested the venue should cancel the event."
The row has emerged amid continuing debate about the Government's decision to proscribe Palestine Action. In June, the Court of Appeal upheld the ban, with judges ruling it was lawful despite acknowledging the organisation remained highly controversial and had supporters who disagreed with the decision.
The event ultimately went ahead. However, the dispute is likely to intensify questions over where the line should be drawn between security concerns and freedom of expression at publicly accessible venues.