Labour has sidestepped claims that the proposed asylum camp at Piddington could cost more than £1bn, with Border Security Minister Anna Turley admitting the Home Office cannot yet confirm the project's cost.
The plan for MoD Bicester, next to the Oxfordshire village of Piddington, would house 1,256 migrants, including 133 women and 46 children. Angela Rayner has faced criticism for fast-tracking planning permission for the accommodation.
Local anger and objections
Liberal Democrat MP for Bicester, Callum Miller, said: "People across Bicester and the surrounding communities are angry about this decision and they have every right to be."
Miller highlighted that the Government recorded 3,177 objections and only one response in favour during consultation. He said: "They took the consultation seriously. The Government recorded 3,177 objections and one response in favour. They raised serious and locally informed questions that deserved answers before planning approval."
He added: "Instead, Government pressed ahead even though they accepted harm to public services, including policing and transport and wider concerns about public safety and community cohesion. The overwhelming impression is that the Government is hellbent on opening another large site and it simply doesn't care about the real and specific problems with this site. I believe it will cost over £1bn to build and operate this centre."
Government response on costs
Turley responded: "The Hon. Gentleman raised the issue of cost… the final per-person costs for MoD Bicester will depend on the outcome of the planning procurement process so I can't comment at this point."
She noted that existing large sites at Weathersfield and Crowborough cost £135 and £138 per night respectively, which is cheaper than hotels at £199 a night. Turley added: "Overall, asylum costs have fallen by over £1bn since this Government came to office."
Safety concerns and legal challenges
Campaigners have declared "they have gravely underestimated us" as they consider multiple legal challenges to block the proposals. Rayner has dismissed women's safety fears, insisting they could be mitigated by CCTV and security guards.
Tory Equalities spokeswoman Joy Morrissey told MPs: "The Government made a choice. They chose to put women and girls in villages like Piddington, Ludgershall and Marsh Gibbon, at risk. Risks they know from the horrific crimes committed by other illegal migrant men against girls as young as 12. They chose to use emergency powers and ignore local opinion. Knowing that these men pose a direct risk to community safety. Men who broke the law in coming here and should be deported. Ministers have got this decision catastrophically wrong. Their choice will have consequences. Consequences they will have to live with. From Piddington to Linton-On-Ouse to Barnham this Government is choosing to ignore the very people they are supposed to put first."
Reform's Richard Tice said: "Constituents will be appalled the Government might spend up to £1billion of taxpayers' cash on opening Piddington, and that the Government accepts that it puts women and girls in the locality at risk. Why not make it a proper detention centre and detain the illegals behind the wire?"
Villagers have warned Prime Minister Andy Burnham, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood and Communities Secretary Ms Rayner they could face jail under Labour's Hillsborough Law if anyone is raped or murdered in the village.
Villager Christina Gower, 26, said: "Disappointment barely scratches the surface of the anger, frustration and betrayal felt by our community. We are a village of approximately 300 adults, including 133 women, and 46 children. To this Government, we appear to be nothing more than collateral damage. A small, rural community whose objections could be brushed aside, whose concerns could be dismissed and whose residents would eventually fall silent. They have gravely underestimated us."