No plans to change Scottish age of consent, says Neil Gray
No plans to change Scottish age of consent, says Neil Gray

The Scottish Government has “no current plans” to change the age of consent, Holyrood Justice Secretary Neil Gray has said, but any proposals would be considered.

Speaking to BBC Radio Scotland on Monday, Gray responded to calls from Mia Latter, an alleged victim of Russell Brand, who waived her right to anonymity to push for a “staggered” age of consent that would make it illegal for adults over a certain age to have sexual relationships with 16 and 17-year-olds.

Government position on consent law

Gray said: “In terms of the general policy principles, we’ll of course consider carefully any evidence-based proposals intended to strengthen protections for young people.

“The age of consent in Scotland is 16 – there are no current plans to change that general position, though I recognise that that high-profile case and other do require thought on what steps we could consider.”

Complexity of a staggered approach

The Justice Secretary described the age of consent as a “complex issue”, noting existing laws protect young people from adults who abuse positions of trust and that staggering the age of consent could make the law less clear.

“At the moment the law is clear, we’ve got very clear rules against anyone in a position of trust engaging in sexual activity with a 16 or 17-year-old and abusing that position,” he said. “Where there is a staggered position, we would need to consider carefully whether that would provide additional complexity to the law that could provide confusion.”

He added: “But these are areas that, of course, we would consider given what has come forward and the very clear interest that there is in ensuring that we are providing safety to young women and girls.”

Political responses

The law in Scotland already protects 16 and 17-year-olds from abuses of trust by adults including teachers, healthcare staff and those working in care settings.

Scottish Lib Dems justice spokeswoman Yi-pei Chou Turvey said considering a staggered age of consent would be an “important step” towards tackling abuse.

“If we’re serious about treating violence against women and girls as an emergency, we have to directly address the power imbalance between older men and teenage girls,” she said. “The sickening scandals that keep emerging demand that government find ways to help protect teenagers from those who take advantage of their vulnerability. Examining the possibility of a staggered age of consent is an important step toward finally tackling this sort of abuse.”

Scottish Tory equalities spokeswoman Meghan Gallacher said the discussion around this kind of abuse must be wider than just the age of consent.

“Too many young people have been horrifically abused by those in positions of power for too long and then found it impossible to get justice,” she said. “It shouldn’t take high-profile scandals for discussions like these to begin. While arguments around any changes to the law of consent would have to be carefully considered, they cannot be the only discussion that is now had.”

Gallacher added: “In SNP-run Scotland, we have seen a spate of violence against young women and girls by dangerous offenders who were often known to them, and who know they will not be properly punished. John Swinney must back up his warm words on this subject that not only educates people, but also properly punishes those responsible and puts victims needs first.”