Residents in Cardiff have called for a new social housing development to be reserved exclusively for people aged 55 and over, amid fears about crime and antisocial behaviour at the site between Fairwater and Llandaff.
At a community meeting attended by more than 200 people at Fairwater Conservative Club on Saturday, November 14, neighbours raised concerns about the current plan, which prioritises accommodation for people on Cardiff’s housing list as well as homeless people.
Residents seek over-55s allocation
Anne Middleton, head of a newly-formed Neighbourhood Watch Group, said: “None of us here fail to understand that these vulnerable people need to be housed in our communities – of course they do. But there is a fear that it is going to attract undesirables to the area.”
Conservative councillor for Llandaff, Sean Driscoll, added: “It’s not going to be a place where you’re going to want your children going to get a bus connection.”
Residents asked for assurances on who will be housed there, who will manage the building, how safety and security will be managed, and whether the impact on existing residents has been considered. They also want details on traffic and parking.
Council and developer absent
However, residents and councillors said they were left without the clarity they had hoped for because Cardiff Council and its partner developer, Wates Residential, did not send a representative to the meeting.
The Waungron Road Housing and Transport Hub development is set for completion in August 2027 and will provide 44 one and two-bed new council apartments, as well as a new transport facility, capable of accommodating up to 40 bus movements per hour.
The £7.7 million Welsh Government grant-funded scheme forms part of Cardiff Council’s Living programme.
According to Wates: “(Flats) will be allocated to people on the city’s housing waiting list (which currently sits at 9,671, more than 27 times the number of empty homes), with some used as temporary supported accommodation for those moving on from homelessness. On-site support staff will help residents take the next step towards independent living.”
Mixed views on proposal
Addressing the meeting, Coun Driscoll said: “I applaud the council for delivering schemes like this across the city.”
Chairing the meeting, Ms Middleton said: “We have chosen to campaign here today to hear the facts first hand (because) in the absence of facts, fear remains strong. Our primary objective is to understand what we need to do to change the current allocation to an over-55s model.”
The objective met with widespread support at the end of the meeting. However, during the meeting, one resident interjected to raise the point that “you can still have over 55s who are prison leavers, who have mental health complexities and drug and alcohol dependencies”.
MS Kiera Marshall of Plaid Cymru told The Cardiffian after the meeting: “I’m not sure the push for the over-55s proposal tackles the real issue. The valid concerns that people in this community have won’t simply be addressed by an age limit. The real issue is an issue of density – choosing to put people with complex needs under the same roof doesn’t actually serve those people or really give them a chance.”
This sentiment was echoed by Coun Driscoll and Councillor Neil McEvoy, leader of Welsh nationalist party, Propel.
Another audience member told The Cardiffian: “I am in my early twenties and I think that the over-55s proposal is restrictive to young people in this community who want to get on the housing ladder.”
Pauline Lomax, a committee member of the South Wales Neighbourhood Watch for over 15 years, suggested that instead of an over-55s model, the building could function as a community space or as a women’s only accommodation. When asked to describe the building, Lomax called it “a beast of a carbuncle” which is “scarring our landscape”.
Petition and next steps
“This project is a council development, on council land,” said Coun Driscoll after the meeting. “I’m telling you now, if the project had been proposed as a private development it would never have seen the light of day.”
In 2021, Coun Driscoll initiated a petition which demanded that Cardiff Council not proceed with construction until current residents were presented with alternative schemes. Despite gathering around 1,500 signatures, this petition was “completely ignored”.
Ms Middleton drew the meeting to a close by echoing her opening comment: “I feel disappointed that we are still asking these questions (six years since planning permission was granted) and we haven’t got the answers out yet. I see a huge outpouring of public concern in front of me. We see this as being the first of many meetings. What we want now is time to think. We would like the council to pause and give us more facts.”
A spokesperson for Cardiff Council said that the Waungron Road Housing Development “will add to the council’s housing stock – allocated to those eligible to join the housing waiting list. The development went through the planning process, which would have included community consultation”.