Liverpool Council chief executive Andrew Lewis has publicly apologised after the long-delayed reopening of Peter Lloyd leisure centre in Tuebrook was described as a “painful experience”. The facility, which dates back to 1987, finally fully reopened in July after six years of setbacks, overspend and delays.
Between 2020 and the summer, those hoping to swim at the Bankfield Road site were forced to go elsewhere after works at the council-run facility massively overran. The dry side of the venue reopened in 2024.
Lessons learned report presented to councillors
Presenting a lessons learned report to city councillors, Mr Lewis issued a public apology for the shortcomings. He admitted the “warts and all” investigation had prompted a lot of “soul searching” within the authority amid repeated calls to get the site open.
As reported by the ECHO, the report detailed how repairs to the site cost the city council £2.7m. Officials said it could have been done cheaper “had the council done things right first time”.
Chief executive admits unacceptable delay
Mr Lewis told members of the culture and economy scrutiny committee the venue was “much loved” in the community with a wide catchment area. He said some of the challenges arose from the building dating back to 1987, with issues first identified in 2013.
The chief executive said periodic closures took place but it was a “building that was difficult to maintain”. He added: “This was an absolutely unacceptable delay. To have a leisure centre close in 2020, for understandable circumstances related to covid, but then not to open until 2024 and for the pool itself to not open until this year was totally unacceptable.”
Cabinet member describes frustrations
Cllr Harry Doyle, cabinet member for health, wellbeing and culture, described getting the site reopened as the “most frustrating piece of work I’ve been involved in since being cabinet member”. He said: “The frustrations were never ending, to be honest with you.”
Cllr Doyle said the findings into the leisure centre failings touched on a “wider corporate issue across the council”. He added how “one of the things I flagged constantly” was no single individual being appointed to manage the project. The cabinet member said: “The organisation did not have one person responsible for capital projects in the council and it was 2023 or 2024 when we actually rectified that.”
The Knotty Ash Labour councillor said the community was let down by the shortcomings of the local authority in restoring the building as were elected representatives. He added: “I sat in these meetings over and over again and rightfully so, challenged by local ward councillors, and the information I was given was the information I was given. It was obviously me who had to deliver that information, I was told opening times on at least five occasions and again let down.”
Apology repeated and future plans
Mr Lewis repeated his apology in the report to “the public, the local residents who would have otherwise been able to enjoy those facilities, to Lifestyles members who were inconvenienced by not having a Lifestyles offer in their immediate area, and our councillors”.
The chief executive said there were “complex technical issues” at the heart of the delays to the pool reopening but recovery of the facility was about “wider weaknesses in the council” particularly how it was not recognised as a major project from the start, describing it as a “legacy project that was not coming together effectively”. Mr Lewis said the newly functioning site was “very much part of future plans” for an expanded leisure service.
Cllr Billy Lake, who represents Tuebrook Larkhill ward, said in his 30 years in the construction industry before becoming a councillor, it was commonplace for an individual to be identified as taking control. He said: “Nobody ever said to me, ‘no-one’s in charge’ on a major project like this was.”
Cllr Lake said: “When a budget is set, you appoint a lead or project manager, that’s how it works. You’re referring to organisational failure, well you cure that at the very start by putting someone in charge, a named person.”
Cllr Steve Radford, of Tuebrook Stoneycroft ward, said he was “bitterly disappointed” by the issue while Cllr Rob McAllister-Bell said he hoped the renewed apologies could go “some way to showing the gravity of the situation”. He added how there had been a “health cost” for young people around Tuebrook and West Derby unable to use the site but claimed some councillors had felt “gaslighted” over the updates they had received about when the venue would reopen.