A significant internal dispute has emerged within the Labour Party regarding the United Kingdom's future relationship with the European Union, following comments made by former health secretary Wes Streeting advocating for eventual re-entry. The row has intensified as the party prepares for a pivotal byelection in Makerfield that could determine the government's fate.
Streeting's Stance on EU Rejoin
Streeting, who resigned from his cabinet position last week in protest against Prime Minister Keir Starmer's leadership, argued on Saturday that Britain's future ultimately lies within the European Union. He stated: "In 2026, the British people increasingly see that in a dangerous world we must club together, both to rebuild our economy and trade, and improve our defence against the shared threats from Russian aggression and America First. The biggest economic opportunity we have is on our doorstep. We need a new special relationship with the EU, because Britain's future lies with Europe – and one day back in the European Union." He also confirmed his intention to stand in any future leadership contest, which is likely if Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham wins the Makerfield byelection and challenges Starmer.
Nandy's Response and Allies' Defence
Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy publicly criticised Streeting's remarks on Sunday, describing them as "a bit odd" during an interview with the BBC's Laura Kuenssberg. Nandy, who also campaigned for Remain, acknowledged that Brexit was a mistake but questioned the sudden focus on Europe. She emphasised the government's pragmatic approach to repairing the damage caused by the Brexit deal without reopening divisive arguments. In response, Streeting's allies defended him, arguing that Nandy's reluctance to discuss EU membership reflects a broader unwillingness within the party to take political risks. One ally remarked: "There is no point in trying not to upset anybody, that's what got us into this problem. Sometimes you have to be willing to upset people to get things done."
Broader Implications for Labour
The disagreement highlights deep divisions within Labour as it approaches the Makerfield byelection, a contest that could trigger a leadership challenge against Starmer. Burnham has declared his candidacy on an explicit promise to challenge the prime minister if elected, following a wave of resignations and mounting pressure from Labour MPs. Although Burnham has not yet been officially selected, he has secured permission from Labour's ruling National Executive Committee, with confirmation expected next week. His allies indicate he would focus on cost-of-living issues and the governance of major utility companies. Labour MP Josh Simons, who is vacating the Makerfield seat to support Burnham, suggested that public ownership of utilities could be a key part of their pitch, citing rising costs for essentials like energy, water, and social housing.
Starmer's Position
Despite the turmoil, Starmer's allies insist he remains determined to stay in office and will contest any leadership race. When asked if Starmer would run, Nandy confirmed: "He said he will … I haven't spoken to him this weekend, but I've spoken to him several times over the last week, and obviously he's shown before that he's up for a fight." The coming weeks will be critical as the byelection campaign unfolds, potentially reshaping the political landscape.
