Residents in Andy Burnham's former mayoral area have called his refusal to rule out re-entry into the European Union a "dictatorship" and "a disgrace". The Prime Minister is seeking to negotiate a new deal with Brussels, which he is expected to say on Monday evening must pass the "Makerfield test" of improving everyday life for his constituency in Greater Manchester and others like it.
Mr Burnham will defend his push for closer ties with Brussels as a "win-win" that reflects his wider approach, with Britain as a "positive player" and not "adversarial" on the world stage. Ahead of the UK-EU summit next week, at which he will seek to lock in mini-deals on food, emissions trading and youth mobility, he will argue the wider post-Brexit agreement secured under Boris Johnson has "not worked".
Public Verdict in Bolton
John Longworth, 74, who used to make the printing plates used by the Bolton Evening News, said while seated on a bench in the centre of the town: "I voted to stay in originally in 1975. I didn't vote for me; I voted for my children and my grandchildren." He said he made the same choice in 2016, adding: "But when the vote went against it, I accepted that." He then slammed the PM, saying it is an "absolute disgrace that he's talking about going back in".
Michael Hogg, 82, who worked in plastics and engineering factories, said in Bolton's high street: "Cameron decided to have this vote and I thought that was brilliant. We are an independent country not run by the Frenchies or the Germans. I don't want to turn it round again."
Leslie Rudd, 69, a retired decorator, also in the town's high street, said regarding the prospect of rejoining: "No. Because we voted to come out. Out we stay. When the British people vote for something, you can't just turn round and say, 'It doesn't suit me; we'll go back in.' That's a dictatorship, not a democracy."
Voices from Manchester Suburbs
John Malone, 48, the landlord at the Shiredale pub in Harpurhey, a Manchester suburb, told the Express he wants a "clean break" with the bloc, and the Government to "stop giving funding to other countries and actually concentrate on this country". He told Mr Burnham: "Leave it as it is. We voted for it, to be out of the EU." Mr Malone thinks the Government does not "listen to what the public want", and he has been left dissatisfied with deals with France to try and curb small boat crossings. Labour's one-in-one-out pact was a "farce from the start", Mr Malone said.
When asked if she thinks re-entering would be a good idea, Caron Withnell, 63, from Oldham simply said: "No." Sue Macky, 73, who used to work as a concierge at flats in Manchester, added in the town's high street: "No." Regarding immigration, she said: "The floodgates are open already and they will be even more open. We need to put a stop on it now." Interestingly, she thinks Britain "should have stayed in it", but now the country should remain out.
She too said Britain is sending too much cash overseas. "Stop spending it on somebody else." Ms Macky used France as an example, whose police, she said, "sit there on the dunes watching" migrants in boats go out to sea on their way to the UK.
Mixed Opinions on Rejoining
Paul Armitage, 58, a retired UNISON union chair, said: "We had a soft Brexit anyway, and we've not really gained from it." He believes Britain would have to "pay levies to get back in", and advantages of staying out or going back in would have to be weighed up. He added: "We didn't have problems with immigration when it was open borders, and there are a lot more problems now." Mr Armitage does not want another referendum, adding he would like to see the Government "try and make the best of it" with "trade agreements with other countries and organisations".
Mark Williams, 66, a retired pilot who lives in Worsley, described the situation as being "like a ratchet". He believes that in order to go back in, it would cost Britain more money than before, and the country would get "less for it". "It is not in their interest to make it a beneficial-looking thing," Mr Williams added. He said it was as if the UK was "under some sort of blackmail". "They still hate us for it," the local, who recently moved to the area from Lincolnshire, said. "I have a house in Italy and a lot of my friends over there are mad. They think we were disgraceful, almost disloyal."
Tracey Freear, 57, the co-owner of Worsley's historic boat dock — the oldest dry dock in the UK's inland waterways system — said of Mr Burnham not ruling out re-entry: "I don't like that, to be honest. We've had a referendum." She added that the Government "listened to the public", and told the PM: "Don't stop listening to them now." Ms Freear thinks Britain "could have a better relationship", but she added: "I don't think we need to go back in."
Kay Williams, 82, said: "We voted and that's it." Her husband, Eric Williams, 83, a retired joiner, is worried about migration. He said: "We've got enough people in the door as it is. Make them work."
Patricia Carline, 88, said in Rochdale: "I don't want to go back in. We've come out now. They [Brussels] want to be nasty anyway, don't they?"
Others were more indifferent, saying there would be pluses and minuses to regaining EU membership. James Bannan, 34, said in Oldham that what Mr Burnham decides to do should depend on whether it would "benefit the actual people or just higher-ups". "At this point, it's Hokey Cokey," he added. The tattooist said that he voted to leave but things are going in "pretty much the same direction regardless". He added that if the UK went back in, things "wouldn't change". Janet Watkins, 67, a retired machinist from Oldham, similarly thinks things would be the same if Britain were to rejoin.
Chris Hodgen, 61, whose profession is in aircraft part manufacturing, said in Rochdale that rejoining would make it easier for people to travel around Europe, but may "again open flood gates" to migrant workers.
Support for Re-entry
Some were more open to the idea of going back in. Florist Louise Morgan, 61, said in Harpurhey that Brexit has not helped the UK, adding: "If [rejoining] meant it was going to help the country, so be it. Life's a moving project. We do our best to move on and try different things."
Caroline Kennedy, 75, a former shop assistant, said in the suburb, "I voted to stay, anyway. I think we're better off [in]." She added that she believed a majority of people would vote to reverse Brexit. Carole Biden, 79, who still works as a residential home housekeeper, said in Oldham: "It's gone downhill since then, hasn't it?"
Fayyad Rahman, 27, an optometrist in the town, said the cost of living has gone "through the roof", and being part of the EU again would "definitely reduce the costs for people".
Adam Murphy, 35, from Worsley, who runs an engineering business, said: "It has had a big impact. It's significantly harder now to trade and operate. People voted to leave solely on immigration." He added: "People feel cheated."
A market worker in Bolton, 62, who did not wish to be named, said re-entry would "help the economy". He also referred to a recent exchange between Mr Burnham and the Conservatives. The Prime Minister claimed new deals with the EU would result in 0.4% growth in GDP. The trader said: "The Conservatives were laughing their heads off in front of him at 0.4%. Basically, that's what we want, really." But he does not think reversing Brexit would be "straightforward" and would happen "very slowly". He added: "You've got to have migration, anyway. We're a multicultural country — and always have been. When people say, '[Migrants] come in and they take, take, take' — they don't. There's good and bad everywhere."
Jonathan Tweedale, 38, who is unemployed after last working in Nando's, said in Rochdale re-entry "probably would be a good idea" as "things have gone extortionate". Alex Lowe, 31, said in Oldham, holding one of his young children, that Brexit was an "absolute disaster" and "wasn't thought through at all". "Issues raised have been made worse," he added.