Brexit Failed Because Freedoms Were Never Used, Not Because Leaving Was Wrong
Brexit Failed Because Freedoms Were Never Used, Not Leaving

Andy Burnham is right that Brexit has not worked, but not because leaving was a mistake. According to political correspondent Aaron Newbury, the UK never used the freedoms it voted for, and Burnham's proposed cure would make things worse.

Ten Years On, Few Feel Better Off

Ten years on from the referendum, few people can say they feel materially better off, that their taxes are lower, or that their high street is busier. Newbury says he struggles to find many people who can answer those questions with a “yes.”

Newbury agrees with Burnham's diagnosis but argues that his proposed cure is entirely wrong. Brexit has not failed because leaving was a mistake, but because the freedom Britons voted for was never used.

Control Left on the Shelf

Britons voted to take back control of laws, borders, and the country, but the government of the day left that control on the shelf. The UK signed on to EU rules where it could and caved to demands to align with the European Parliament.

Where the UK did dare to diverge, the results were promising. Britain joined the CPTPP, a Pacific trade bloc the EU is not part of, and England freed its farmers to grow hardier crops through gene editing.

Burnham's Answer Would Make It Worse

Newbury argues that successive governments treated Brexit as damage to be managed, not an opportunity to be seized. Burnham's answer is to tie the UK to a bloc that is going nowhere fast, with the European Commission's own forecast showing the eurozone growing by just 1.2% this year, with inflation at 3.2%.

At the upcoming summit in Brussels, Burnham wants to sign Britain up to EU food rules and link the UK's carbon market to theirs, meaning taking laws the UK has no vote on from a club it chose to leave.

Rejoining Would Be Worse Still

Rejoiners have a point on trade: agri-food exports to the EU did fall after the UK left, and paperwork at the border has made things harder. But the solution cannot be to hand Brussels the pen. Rejoining would surrender the freedoms the UK has used and almost certainly lose the rebate Margaret Thatcher fought to win.

The honest answer to a Brexit that has not worked is not to give up on it. The government must finally deliver it by scrapping rules that hold back British business, cutting taxes that strangle growth, and striking trade deals Brussels never could. Brexit was meant to be the beginning of a new story, and it is time someone in Downing Street had the courage to write the next chapter.