Emmerdale fans are convinced they have uncovered the true identity of Serena Sugden's biological father, with many pointing to Graham Foster as the likely candidate. The newcomer, played by Casey Al-Shaqsy, debuted last month when she helped a distressed Charity Dingle by the lake. The two formed a bond as Charity confided about baby Leyla's paternity and Dr. Caitlin Todd's blackmail and sexual assault.
Serena's Suspicious Actions
After supporting Charity, Serena arrived in the village to reconnect with her long-lost family. She quickly bonded with her cousin Robert Sugden, who let her stay at Butler's Farm. However, Robert's fiancé Aaron Dingle remains wary of Serena, especially after she repeatedly asked about Robert's serial killer brother John.
Kev Barton recently revealed that Serena is a police officer, prompting Robert to confront her. During Wednesday's episode, Serena explained she left the force because it "weren't a good fit." She also disclosed that John had withdrawn his army pension to help her family financially, and she offered the remaining money to Tracy Robinson, Nate's widow.
Serena's Investigation
After extracting information from Bob Hope, Serena deduced that Victoria's departure was linked to John's death. Viewers recall that Victoria killed John in self-defence during the Corriedale crossover, though his death was ruled a suicide. Serena reassured Robert: "If she did kill John, I'd be buying her a drink, not turning her in. I won't take it any further." However, she was later seen outside the police station, suggesting she may report Victoria.
Graham Foster Theory
Many fans now suspect Serena is not a Sugden but Graham Foster's daughter. Graham returned from the dead earlier this year. One fan posted: "Am I the only one that isn't sure about Serena Sugden?" Another added: "I don't think she's a Sugden." A third commented: "She could be something to do with Graham, maybe his daughter?" A fourth shared: "She would actually fit in really well with the Tate's because she's so dodgy."
What's Next?
Emmerdale airs weeknights at 8pm on ITV1 and ITVX. The storyline continues to unfold, with Serena's true parentage and motives still unclear.
