A new Channel 4 documentary has revealed the disturbing messages sent by Holly Willoughby's would-be kidnapper to the undercover investigator who helped stop him. Gavin Plumb, 39, was convicted in July 2024 of soliciting murder and inciting rape and kidnap of the former This Morning presenter.
Undercover officer's chilling discovery
The former security guard, who had an 'unhealthy sexual obsession' with Willoughby, is serving life with a minimum term of 16 years. David Nelson, an alias used by a detective from a police department in Minnesota, was undercover in the online chat group 'Abduct Lovers' from around 2021, where he encountered Plumb.
Nelson told the documentary how Plumb sent him hundreds of messages, sharing plans to 'overpower Holly at her home with chloroform, sexually assault her and dump her body'. The investigator escalated the case to the FBI after Plumb shared video proof of his 'restraint kit', which included a ball gag, shackles, handcuffs and various restraints.
Investigator's account
'I see a lot of messed-up stuff working in cyberspace,' Nelson recalls. 'But for someone to have all those materials collected and spread out on the bed like a trophy shot, it was extremely disturbing.'
'When I saw that video, I knew this was gonna be something we were going to have to move with real quick or things were going to get real bad,' he added.
The documentary, The Plot to Kidnap Holly Willoughby, reveals how Plumb was unaware he was communicating with an undercover cop. Nelson had to put Plumb off attempting a practice run of his plot on a woman he called his 'fit-a** neighbour'.
Details of the plot
Nelson, who used the username 'Big Bear', first contacted Plumb after he posted pictures of Willoughby on the site. Plumb responded cagily, 'Why do you think?', before Nelson replied on October 3, 2023, writing: 'Alright, I'll bite. Who's the hottie?'
Plumb insisted he had 'a s**tload of info on her' and later boasted that he had 'everything to hold her and chloroform'. When Nelson responded, 'Stfu (shut the f**k up). You serious?', Plumb sent a photo of a bottle of the chemical. When Nelson asked if he had weapons, Plumb replied with a photo of a knife.
Plumb was looking to recruit someone to help him 'carry out his ultimate fantasy' with Willoughby, which was 'to conduct a home invasion, put her in a vehicle, drive her to an unknown space, sexually assault her. And then we're going to leave her body in a body of water'.
While sharing his plans, Plumb unknowingly helped Nelson 'narrow down where I needed to go and who I needed to work with'. 'He shared that he was from Essex and that he was a security guard for a pharmaceutical company. He constantly shared images during the conversation. We would be in the middle of a topic and he may just drop four or five images of Holly. His excitement just continued to go up and up and up,' the investigator remembered.
Arrest and aftermath
Nelson reached out to the FBI, who contacted the UK's National Crime Agency. Essex Police later told Nelson Plumb's identity, and he realised Willoughby was 'in extreme danger'. He kept chatting with Plumb online ahead of his arrest so that his device would be open and searchable when police descended on his home in Harlow.
Plumb had previously attempted to abduct two air hostesses on a train in 2006, for which he received a 12-month suspended sentence, and attacked and attempted to tie-up two teenage girls in a Woolworths stockroom in 2008, for which he served 32 months in prison.
Willoughby said this year that the plot had changed her perspective on life, now she knew 'what real fear feels like'. Talking about launching her new YouTube lifestyle channel Together in July, she told Grazia: 'This shouldn't be scary. This should be something really enjoyable. If it doesn't work, it doesn't work. But you have to have a go. What's the other option? Just sitting scared and never doing a thing again?'
The ex-Dancing on Ice star also said she'd learned she's 'very resilient' following the case but was clear she won't let it define her. 'It's another life experience that adds another layer and makes you a bit more empathetic to other people in similar situations,' she explained. 'Everything in life teaches you something, and I definitely had a hard lesson to learn. I'm not going to sit here and go, "I'm so strong now", because I'm not, but I'm stronger in many ways.'
Last month Plumb saw his appeal against his sentence rejected, after judges at the Court of Appeal ruled that he had intended harm 'of the gravest and highest possible kind' and that his sentence was appropriate. The Plot to Kidnap Holly Willoughby airs on Monday at 9pm on Channel 4.