Fans of the classic British period drama Upstairs, Downstairs are claiming that the hit series Downton Abbey copied its premise and characters. The debate has reignited as viewers compare the two shows, which both focus on an upper-class family and their servants.
Similar Premises
Upstairs, Downstairs originally aired from 1970 to 1975, predating Downton Abbey by four decades. Both shows share a similar setting—an upper-class household and their domestic staff—and cover overlapping time periods. Fans have noted numerous similarities, with one Reddit user stating: “I like Downton Abbey better, but Upstairs, Downstairs is the better show. Julian Fellowes blatantly copied a few things from UD.”
Viewer Reactions
Another viewer commented: “I’m watching upstairs downstairs right now and I’ve already been like 'wait that was in DA'. What stood out immediately is the daughter being politically active but then the gay footman who has a relationship with the baron. Alfred and Thomas have very similar timelines right now.” A third added: “Julian Fellowes ripped off 65% of the UD characters' names and plots for Downton.”
However, not everyone agrees. One fan defended both shows: “They are very different shows from very different eras (70s vs 2010s). I loved Upstairs/Downstairs when it aired. I love DA. I don't think a show from 40 years ago should be compared to a modern one.”
Reboot and Legacy
The BBC rebooted Upstairs, Downstairs in 2010, the same year Downton Abbey debuted. The reboot received mixed reviews and lasted only two series. The Guardian reviewed the two shows, stating: “Downton Abbey v Upstairs Downstairs – who won? Downton Abbey, of course.” The review noted that Downton Abbey changed how audiences watch period drama, with tight scripting and a campy wink.
Upstairs, Downstairs (1970-1975) is available to watch on ITVX, while the 2010 reboot streams on U.
