Top of the Lake, a BBC police drama set in a remote New Zealand town, is being hailed by viewers as "seriously underrated" and "better than The Fall" as they binge-watch both series. The show, which aired for two series on the BBC, is available to stream for free on Channel 4 and U.
What Top of the Lake is about
Elisabeth Moss, known for The Handmaid's Tale and Mad Men, stars as Detective Robin Griffin, who investigates the disappearance of a pregnant 12-year-old girl in an isolated mountain town. The detective battles her own dark past while working on the case, which involves a schoolgirl last seen wading into a freezing lake.
Moss appeared in the show between her breakthrough role in Mad Men and her Emmy-winning performance in The Handmaid's Tale. The first series also featured David Wenham and Peter Mullan, while Nicole Kidman and Game of Thrones star Gwendoline Christie joined the cast for the second series. Filmmaker Jane Campion, the Oscar winner behind The Piano and The Power of the Dog, co-created the programme.
What viewers say
The first series received widespread acclaim, with a Rotten Tomatoes rating of 95%. Critics have described it as "a masterpiece" that will "leave you on the edge of your seat". The website's critics' consensus reads: "Absorbing and deeply atmospheric, Top of the Lake takes edgy, disturbing content and delivers powerful performances with lasting impressions."
One viewer recommended the show, saying: "I've just binge-watched 'Top of The Lake' with Elisabeth Moss... and her performance is A-MAZING. I highly recommend it, Moss is a hell of an actress, so it's true she's the only one not doing anything to find volumes of good and diverse stuff to work with after Mad Men." Another fan replied: "I think Top of the Lake is seriously underrated. I really liked it, and agree she was fantastic in it."
An IMDb user review dubbed it "better than The Fall", explaining: "Most shows bore when they get slow, but this show draws you in and makes you appreciate its slow pace. For god sakes, it took 'The Killing' two seasons to tell me who killed the girl. [...] This is so unlike this series. You cannot group these two together. It is a very unique insight into humans and our reasonings. With many twists and turns, I highly recommend this show."
Viewers have also compared it to Twin Peaks, with one saying: "I mention it in the same breath as Broadchurch and True Detective and any well-made Scandinavian murder mystery. It has a beautiful sense of place, both geographically and the community. New Zealand is gorgeous. David Wenham and Elizabeth Moss both knock it out of the park. It is a worthy descendant of Twin Peaks. It has possibly grown up a bit smarter, too; it doesn't trivialise its subject matter with quirkiness for better or worse."
Second series and where to watch
The show's pervasive sense of unease and captivating cinematography may feel familiar, as the first series shares cinematographer Adam Arkapaw with the first series of True Detective, despite the New Zealand mountains being worlds apart from the Louisiana bayous.
Originally conceived as a miniseries, Top of the Lake returned for a second run in which Detective Griffin has returned to Sydney and investigates the death of a girl discovered at Bondi Beach with surprising personal links. It received more mixed reviews but still achieved a "fresh" status on Rotten Tomatoes with a 71% rating.
Both series of Top of the Lake, each six episodes long, are available to stream for free on Channel 4 and U.