EastEnders fans are convinced another DNA twist is on the way as Penny Branning finally confesses her paternity secret to Gina Knight, with Harry Mitchell suspected as baby Ethan's real father.
Penny (Kitty Castledine) has been hiding the possibility that Vinny Panesar (Shiv Jalota) is not the father of her son Ethan, as she slept with Harry Mitchell (Elijah Holloway) before getting together with Vinny. During her first ultrasound in late March 2026, Penny learned she was further along in her pregnancy than expected, indicating that the tot's father was Harry.
Penny's Secret Unravels
Penny initially confided in her cousin Lauren Beale (Jacqueline Jossa), then went to extreme lengths to keep Vinny in the dark, including using a forged DNA result after being confronted by Nicola Mitchell (Laura Doddington). Following Ethan's birth in September, various family members from the Brannings and Panesars have commented that the newborn has a complexion dissimilar to Vinny's, including Priya Nandra-Hart (Sophie Khan Levy).
On Thursday's episode (November 19), Penny and Vinny continued with their lie that they are engaged after Gina Knight (Francesca Henry) fibbed to impress a business investor called Caitlin. Jack Branning (Scott Maslen) was buying champagne for everyone in The Vic to celebrate his daughter's engagement, as Suki Panesar (Balvinder Sopal) also looked slightly happy for her son.
Confession at Harry's Bar
However, the couple were eventually forced to explain that they weren't actually planning to get married, leaving everyone baffled. Suki and Jack were left disappointed and encouraged the couple to get engaged after all, given they share a child and are madly in love, and Vinny soon realised he wanted to marry Penny for real. But as he started proposing to her, Penny raced out of The Vic.
Eventually, Gina, who is dating Harry, tracked down Penny at Harry's Bar and knew there was more than just her views on marriage troubling her best pal. When she grilled Penny, she admitted to keeping a huge secret, telling Gina that Vinny might not be Ethan's dad. Before Penny could confess anything else, Vinny arrived.
Viewers Predict Another Twist
Despite Penny being convinced that Harry is Ethan's father, EastEnders viewers are predicting another twist - Vinny has been the father all along, but their relationship will be over thanks to her deceit. Taking to X, one person contemplated whether Ethan could look mixed-race, adding: "I'm sure the real twist is that he's Vinny's", while a second added: "I hate they're messing up Penny and Vinny for no reason #eastenders."
On Reddit, another EastEnders fan asked: "Does she actually know? I thought she didn't do the DNA test in the end," while another stated: "No, she doesn't know, the baby could still be Vinny's (not impossible given skin colour is not determinative, albeit perhaps less likely)." "Even if Ethan does turn out to be Vinny's son (and that’s still a possibility, given that Penny hasn't bothered to get an official DNA test), the damage is already done", feared one viewer.
"I haven't been in Penny's situation, but seriously! She's made it so much worse for herself, because she didn't actually cheat on Vinny. Now, she's spent months lying to him and he'll be, rightfully, devastated/angry. I still hope Ethan turns out to be his", wrote another. EastEnders airs Monday to Thursday on BBC One and iPlayer.