Channel 4 chief executive Priya Dogra has said she cancelled Married At First Sight UK (Mafs UK) because she was “uncomfortable” with the changes recommended for the show to continue. The broadcaster axed the reality dating show following an external review triggered by “serious allegations of wrongdoing”.
Review Recommendations and Allegations
Some of the recommendations in the review included “providing two lockable ensuite bedrooms or (if no ensuite) a lockable bathroom with an extra bolt inside”, and installing CCTV cameras in apartments to be monitored 24/7 by a welfare team.
The move came after former participant Shona Manderson appeared in a BBC Panorama documentary that aired in May, accusing her on-screen partner of sexual misconduct while filming the Channel 4 show. Two other anonymous women who participated in the programme alleged they were raped by their on-screen husbands.
In June, a Mafs UK cast member was arrested on suspicion of rape. All three men deny the claims.
Channel 4 CEO's Decision
A review was commissioned by Ms Dogra into the programme, the results of which prompted her to end the show. The review had two elements: law firm Clyde & Co examined the welfare protocols in place at the time the claims were initially raised, and how Channel 4 and production company CPL handled them; while former BBC One controller Lorraine Heggessey examined if any changes should be made to current protocols for Mafs UK to further strengthen contributor welfare.
Ms Dogra told MPs on the Department For Culture Media And Sport (DCMS) Committee that “the wholesale implication of those recommendations would have made a completely different show”. She added: “There were also aspects of the recommendations that, frankly, I was uncomfortable with.”
“They would involve 24/7 recording, not for broadcast but for monitoring and editorial. There was talk of double locking rooms and bathrooms and I didn’t feel that was a show that I wanted to be making. Ultimately, I made that decision.”
Financial Impact and Regulatory Response
Ms Dogra acknowledged that Mafs UK was a “very profitable show” for Channel 4 and said: “To say it won’t be a loss to the financials would be wrong, of course it will.” She said she learned of the allegations in the Panorama documentary just four weeks into her job as chief executive officer.
She said: “We always intended to do the review, whether the programme was out in public knowledge or not. We did a thorough review and Clyde looked at something like 30,000 documents at the time.”
Ofcom has since strengthened its industry guidance to protect the welfare of participants in “constructed reality programmes” in the wake of Mafs UK ending. The regulator has added the guidance to its fairness rules under the Broadcasting Code (Section Seven) to include a new section relating to reality shows which involve physical and/or emotional intimacy.
The new guidance emphasises that the greater the expectation put on contributors to engage in physical or emotional intimacy, “the greater the potential risk to harm”. The regulator said programme-makers should be aware that the establishment of “new relationships” on reality shows “may lead to harmful behaviour among participants” including sexual misconduct and coercive control. The guidance encouraged consent to be an “ongoing process” where broadcasters should revisit contributors’ consent whenever circumstances change during filming, such as following confrontations or physical intimacy.