Netflix subscribers are issuing stark warnings to fellow viewers over the platform's latest high-profile release, a Western drama that has spectacularly split opinion. The seven-episode series 'The Abandons', which debuted on the 4th of December 2025, boasts A-list talent but has left a significant portion of its audience feeling profoundly disappointed.
A Star-Studded Letdown?
Featuring 'Game of Thrones' icon Lena Headey and 'The X-Files' favourite Gillian Anderson, the show promised a potent blend of star power and gritty storytelling. Set against the breathtaking landscapes of Canada, the narrative follows two formidable women locked in a brutal conflict over land and family legacy. However, the anticipated collaboration has, for many, failed to deliver on its gripping trailer's promise.
On review aggregator sites like Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb, a wave of negative feedback has emerged. One viewer, Tuckerbox, awarded a scathing one-star review, complaining the opening scenes "looked like it was AI and didn't get any better." Another, kirsty888888, branded the show "shockingly bad," criticising its weak storylines, writing, and acting, which left them with a feeling of time wasted.
Critics vs. Audience: A Growing Chasm
The backlash highlights a growing disconnect between critical reception and viewer satisfaction. While some professional reviews were favourable, audience members have been quick to pan the series. Reviewer Jonathon Wilson noted the show felt "cobbled-together and thin," questioning its entertainment value. Another lamented that not even Headey and Anderson's considerable talents could save the project, suggesting it was only "watchable" for those with time to kill.
Despite the torrent of criticism, the series has its defenders. Some fans have praised the leading performances, with Michele K on Rotten Tomatoes awarding five stars and stating, "Lena Headey carries this show." Another on IMDb, paulwatts-71889, gave it eight out of ten, appreciating the "potent mix" of placing two great mature actresses in a Western land-grab script.
What This Means for Netflix Subscribers
The intensely mixed reception for 'The Abandons' serves as a cautionary tale about the unpredictable nature of streaming hits. With viewer trust increasingly guided by peer reviews on social media and aggregate sites, a divided response can significantly impact a show's longevity and cultural footprint. For now, the advice from a vocal segment of the Netflix community is clear: proceed with caution before investing time in this particular Western saga. All episodes of 'The Abandons' are currently available to stream on Netflix.
